Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Investment bank fails- there aren’t enough viable profitable projects to invest in- state and local govs can’t pay back the loans

Charles Marohn June 14, 2021

A National Infrastructure Bank is a Stupid Idea; Strong Towns; https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2021/6/14/a-national-infrastructure-bank-is-a-stupid-idea

The other part of the fairy tale is the notion that there are worthy projects out there, investments that pay an actual financial return. There just isn’t, at least not at the scale that a national infrastructure bank would look to fund. Let me make sure we are all on the same page with what an “actual financial return” is. Say your city borrows $1 million to install a new sewer pipe in the ground. A real financial return would mean that the city, once they deducted their expenses, had new revenue from the installation of that pipe sufficient to retire that $1 million debt, plus interest. If those projects existed (and they really don’t anymore), they are easily funded. What cities are actually struggling with isn’t money for expansion but money for maintaining what they already have. It’s the backlog of past promises that is financially strangling them, and borrowing money from an infrastructure bank is not going to fix that insolvency problem. For example, Flint, Michigan, can borrow all the money it wants right now and use that money to fix their lead pipes. They can borrow the money, they just have no means to pay it back. And since replacing lead pipes with non-lead pipes is not exactly expected to supercharge growth in Flint, it’s not like there is an expectation of additional tax revenue that can be dedicated to loan repayment. Local government debt is not a federal revenue stream. An infrastructure bank would try to make it one, but it doesn’t work that way, at least not if the bank wants to remain solvent.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.