FIB won’t generate the financing needed- state banks prove
Robert Krol 2017
Does a National Public Infrastructure Bank Make Sense?; Mercatus Center @ George Mason University; https://www.mercatus.org/economic-insights/expert-commentary/does-national-public-infrastructure-bank-make-sense
This is a naïve view. State infrastructure banks offer valuable lessons as to why a federal bank is unlikely to become a long-term, sustainable source of funding. The 1995 National Highway System Designation Act established a state infrastructure bank pilot program. Since then 34 states set up public infrastructure banks. The initial capital came mostly from federal and some state tax dollars. According to tallies by Brookings Institution researchers Robert Puentes and Jennifer Thompson, these banks made 1,134 agreements worth $7.4 billion between 1995 and 2012, amounting to one-half-of-one percent of total state spending on infrastructure over the period. Seventy percent of the agreements were for highway construction. However, rather than making traditional loans, 28 percent of the agreements were issued interest free—defeating the goal of providing a sustainable source of infrastructure funding. Today, many of these banks are inactive or require addition taxpayer dollars. A national infrastructure bank would presumably allow firms to borrow at the Treasury bond interest rate, an attractive feature to private borrowers. But state and local governments—traditionally the main borrowers in this case—have historically been able to borrow at lower rates. Interest rates on infrastructure bank loans would have to be below the state and local rate in order to entice them to borrow from the bank. Again, this is a problem if the goal is a sustainable source of infrastructure investment funds.