Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

No solvency – impractical, expensive, negative effects

Govindswamy ‘9 Bala, climatologist at the Indian Institute of Science - Bangalore - McGill University, (“Problems with geoengineering schemes to combat climate change”, 9/22/08, http://indiaenvironmentportal.org.in/files/Problems%20with%20geoengineering%20schemes.pdf)//RN

The conclusion of the 1992 NAS report13 was that most geoengineering schemes, though feasible, are impractical, cumbersome to manage, or too expensive. It suggested some further study, but did not find it worthy of great effort. In support of this conclusion, Schneider29 suggested to reduce slowly our economic dependence on carbon fuels, rather than try to counter the side effects using risky options such as centuries of injecting sulphur into the atmosphere or iron into the oceans. While acknowledging that all geoengineering schemes have serious flaws, Keith10 judged that this century is likely to see serious debates about geoengineering. The serious debate indeed started when Nobel laureate Paul Crutzen8 published his influential editorial article on geoengineering. Since the attempts to curb fossil-fuel emissions have been unsuccessful, Crutzen suggested that the usefulness of artificially enhancing the planetary albedo to counteract the climate forcing of growing CO2 emissions might again be explored and debated. In a series of editorial comments8,30–33, broad recommendations were made to pursue scientific research on the effects of geoengineering schemes. However, Bengtsson34 expressed his reservations against geoengineering schemes for the following reasons. (1) There is a lack of accuracy in climate prediction. (2) There is large difference in the timescale between the effects of CO2 and the effects of aerosols, forcing us to commit to the artificial release of aerosols for several hundred years. (3) There are serious environmental problems such as ocean acidification, which are not mitigated by the albedoenhancing geoengineering schemes. To address the last two issues, Wigley advocated a combination of mitigation and geoengineering to prevent both climate change and ocean acidification. And thus the debate on combating climate change via geoengineering continues3

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.