BI would transform gender relationships and empower women
Beth Goldblatt ‘20, University of Oxford, Professor, Faculty of Law, University of Technology Sydney; Visiting Professor, School of Law, University of the Witwatersrand. “Basic Income, Gender and Human Rights,” University of Oxford Human Rights Hub Journal, 3.1 https://ohrh.law.ox.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/U-of-OxHRH-J-Basic-Income-Gender-and-Human-Rights-1.pdf - Annie
Economic inequality has profound gender dimensions. As Oxfam’s 2020 report notes, the global ‘economic system is built on sexism’.77 The major burden of caring in all societies falls on women who largely provide this work without pay. This work impacts on women’s access to paid work and other economic opportunities and contributes to the gender pay gap found across the world. 78 Oxfam estimates the value of women’s unpaid care work at $10.8 trillion annually which is three times the size of the world’s tech industry.79 Sexism is a key driver of wealth inequality and also impacts directly on women’s income. Women are likely to fill the most precarious and poorest paid positions in society and to earn significantly lower wages than men.80 Technological and other drivers of un- and under employment are thus likely to impact harshly on women workers. At the same time, austerity policies and service cuts disadvantage women and girls more than men as the burden shifts from the state to the household.81 Feminists have long recognised that the capitalist system profits from the unpaid labour of women through the social and biological reproduction of society.82 It is this fault line, premised on women’s biological difference but deeply embedded in social structures, that hampers women’s progression in the job market and economy. The challenging global context and long-standing impact of sexism have important implications for the forms of social protection that can both mitigate the effects of gender inequality and contribute to its eradication. There is an emerging acknowledgment of the need for such measures. The UN’s Sustainable Development Goals, one of which is aimed at achieving gender equality (Goal 5) targets the recognition and valuing of ‘unpaid care and domestic work through the provision of public services, infrastructure and social protection policies and the promotion of shared responsibility within the household and the family as nationally appropriate.’83 Which social protection policies will best address gender divisions of work and care alongside the broader challenges of poverty and inequality facing the world is a key question. Basic income, posited by many as a solution to the challenges of inequality and work, has been of interest to feminists grappling with the sexual division of labour in the home and workplace and its dire consequences for women. Proponents of a basic income suggest it has value for women in delinking social security from work given the disadvantages faced by women in the job market.84 Work interruptions to have children and fulfil care roles result in shorter careers, lower wages and smaller accumulation of retirement savings for women, making them more dependent on men and vulnerable in old age. A basic income could enhance women’s freedom to make life choices, including allowing them to live independently of men at different stages of their lives. 85 This is an important consideration given the economic vulnerability facing single mothers and single older women in many countries, worsened by austerity and economic crisis. A basic income would enable women to leave violent relationships if they were assured of income for themselves and their children.86 A basic income has also been supported as a necessary means of enhancing women’s democratic citizenship. 87 By focusing on reciprocity across the society, the debate about a basic income can open up conversations about reciprocity within the household. 88 A basic income recognises unpaid and affiliative work as socially valuable and thus has the potential to change understandings of social citizenship. 89 The shift from work to citizenship as the source of income thus increases the possibility of transformed gender relations. Nancy Fraser’s transformative model of citizenship, ‘the universal care-giver model’, sees all members of society participating in paid work and unpaid care with social institutions restructured to support this.90 A basic income, or some variant of it, might enable this change leading to a more equal division of care and work.91 Cox suggests reframing basic income as a ‘universal social dividend’ since this would ‘redefine such income as produced by valuing wide-ranging unpaid contributions to collective social well-being and counter some of the materialist gender inequities of economic models’.92 The challenge to decommodify human activity so that ‘affiliative’ work is valued must be built into policies aimed at achieving gender equality.93 Pateman points out that a feminist lens reorients the basic income debate away from economic questions to ones related to democratisation since it focuses on issues of citizenship and institutions including the workplace and marriage.94 While the debate is often concerned with ‘free-riding’, those who choose not to work while depending on the income of others, a feminist understanding shifts the examination of free-riding to men who continue to expect women to perform the bulk of social reproductive work within their households even when both partners are in paid employment. The idea of a basic income paid to individual women as a citizenship entitlement rather than to the household where it may not be shared equally is important for feminism and democratisation.95