Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Basic income reduces gendered violence in relationships by reducing dependence on abusive partners and freeing women from exploitative jobs.

Clark ’21 (Rebecca L Clark, doctoral candidate in political theory at Nuffield College, University of Oxford, “Should Feminists Endorse a Universal Basic Income?”, University of Oxford, 3/18/2021, http://blog.practicalethics.ox.ac.uk/2021/03/oxford-uehiro-prize-in-practical-ethics-should-feminists-endorse-a-universal-basic-income/#_ftn2)- CSC

I now turn to a second criterion for gender justice enhancement, which I deem to be highly plausible: Anti-Exploitation Criterion: all else being equal, a reduction in gendered exploitation is gender-justice enhancing. I consider a form of exploitation to be gendered if it is systematically the case that, in a given type of exploitable dependency relationship, the subordinate agent is a woman[11]. Fraser identifies three common types of exploitable dependencies: on a family member, on a boss, and on a state official.[12] A UBI would mitigate the exploitation of each of these types of dependencies, which are plausibly construed as gendered, and hence is prima facie gender-justice enhancing. Firstly, consider the exploitable dependence of wives on their husbands in many traditional heterosexual marriages. Their relative lack of economic independence renders these women exploitable by their husbands with respect to the allocation of unpaid housework, the satisfaction of sexual desires, the provision of emotional labour, and more. A key advantage of a UBI is that it is given to individuals rather than households; this reduces the exploitable dependence of women on their partners in two ways. First, it gives women a credible means to leave emotionally or physically abusive relationships, thereby directly lessening their exploitation. Second, even if this exit option is not in fact utilised, its mere existence lessens the asymmetric vulnerability of women within a marriage. Secondly, a UBI would reduce gendered exploitation in the market for intimate labour, defined as “work that is done primarily by women with intimate parts of their bodies or their intimate physical capacities in exchange for money, favours, or goods” [13] such as sex work or commercial surrogacy. Many women undertake intimate labour solely due to economic deprivation, a concern which a UBI would alleviate. Moreover, even a UBI set below a livable wage would meaningfully improve the negotiating power of women who perform intimate labour, giving them greater freedom to turn down more dangerous clients such as those who insist on having unprotected sex. Thirdly, the undemocratic discretion of state officials opens the door to the exploitation of welfare recipients. Due to its unconditional nature, a UBI would protect individuals from low-income households from being as vulnerable to the whim of bureaucrats. To the extent that welfare recipients are disproportionately women, this would mitigate gendered exploitation.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.