Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

War inevitable and unending under patriarchy – the disad’s framing reifies masculine ways of conceptualizing international relations.

Peet and Sjoberg, 2020 (Laura Sjoberg, Professor of Political Science at U Florida; the Late Jessica Peet taught IR at the University of Florida and USC. Introduction to Gender and Civilian Victimization in War (Print Book), SPP)

As scholars, the "lenses" we use "foreground some things, and background others" in our research (V. Peterson and Runyan 1999). Our research questions start with the ideas, concepts, and variables we see as most important in global politics. For example, the scholars who have written on intentional civilian victimization have started with the ideas, concepts, and variables they see as most important in global politics, including regime type, international law, strategy, and culture. Like other scholars in IR, feminist work uses "lenses" to foreground variables of particular interest, specifically sex, gender, and sexuality; gender identity; and gender hierarchy, using "gender lenses" to view global politics (V. Peterson and Runyan 1999: 2). Looking through gender lenses is a way "to focus on gender as a particular kind of power relation, or to trace out the ways in which gender is central to understanding international processes" (Steans 1998: 5). While women's oppression is a primary concern for feminists, "the driving force of feminism is its attention to gender and not simply to women .... [T]he concept, nature and practice of gender are key" (Zalewski 1995). Feminists, then, "ask what assumptions about gender (and race, class, nationality, and sexuality) are necessary to make particular statements, policies, and actions meaningful" (Wilcox 2009). In our analysis of civilian victimization, we focus on how the concept, nature, and practice of gender influences states' and other war-fighting parties' decisions to target civilians and ask what assumptions about gender are necessary to make intentional civilian victimization appealing, despite the non-combatant immunity norm. With this focus, we also look at the intersections of gender, race, ethnicity, and nationalism in constituting both the idea of the civilian and her vulnerability. In order to fully grasp why those are important questions, we need to spend a little time understanding what feminists mean by 'sex' and by 'gender' in this context. Many people see sex as biology - male and fem ale sex organs make people men or women. 4 In the conventional wisdom, then, gender is directly related to, and maps onto, sex - men are masculine and women are feminine. However, feminist scholarship has "questioned the conventional assumption that gender differences (and subordination) are rooted in biological differences between women and men" (Scott 1987; Sjoberg 2006a: 32). Instead, feminist scholars suggest that the relation between sex and gender is presumed rather than natural, where masculinity and femininity are separable from maleness and femaleness. Masculine characteristics, like strength, protectiveness, rationality, aggressiveness, presence in public life, domination, and leadership, then, are perceived as related to maleness, while in reality they are not reserved for men. Conversely, traits associated with femininity, like weakness, vulnerability, emotion, passivity, privacy, submission, and care, are assumed to be the domain of women, while that is not always or even normally the case. Genderings can be read into and back onto sex, which is malleable rather than set, and co-constituted with gender (e.g., Butler 1990, 1993). Applying this understanding, gender cannot be operationalized as a 'yes' or 'no' (or 'male' or 'female' question), or as a matter of degree. It also cannot be accounted for by asking questions about 'what women do' differently than 'what men do' in global politics.5 Instead, it is more of a constellation of significations, where masculinities and femininities are mutually constituted (along with race, class, sexuality, etc.) in specific, hierarchical relation to one another - where ( often) masculinities are prized and powerful, while femininities are seen as undesirable and therefore subordinated. In this context, we can talk not just about men and women and masculinities and femininities but of masculinism and feminization. Masculinism is the prizing of masculinities and the exclusion and/ or devaluing of femininities in social and/ or political contexts. Masculinism leads to feminization - the devaluing of femininities by putting down or putting aside people, groups, or ideas associated with femininities and by associating devalued or marginalized people, groups, or ideas with femininities (V. Peterson 2010; see also V. Peterson and Runyan 2010). 6 V. Spike Peterson describes feminization as devalorization: Not only subjects (women and marginalized men), but also concepts, desires, tastes, styles, "ways of knowing" ... can be feminized - with the effect of reducing their legitimacy, status and value. Importantly, this devalorization is simultaneously ideological (discursive, cultural) and material (structural, economic) .... This devalorization normalizes - with the effect of "legitimating" - the marginalization, subordination, and exploitation of feminized practices and persons ... the "naturalness" of sex difference is generalized to the "naturalness" of masculine (not necessarily male) privilege, so that both aspects come to be taken-for -granted "givens" of social life (V. Peterson 2010). In this vein, a key tenet of feminist theorizing about the global political arena is that it is gender -hierarchical (Sjoberg 2009). Though masculinities and femininities are detectable across known human history, they are not static, temporally, geographically, or culturally. Quite the opposite, the dominant 'masculinity' or 'femininity' is different at different times, and in different places and cultures. While "the exact content of genders varies with various and shifting socio-political contexts, ... gender subordination (defined as the subordination of femininities to masculinities) remains a constant feature of social and political life across time and space" (Sjoberg and Gentry 2007: 9). Feminist research in IR, then, asks how these complex notions of gender constitute and influence the realities of everyday life in global politics . In this book, we are particularly interested in how gender influences belligerents' (especially states') decisions to attack civilians in war in conjunction with other parts of the 'puzzle' of intentional civilian victimization. Thinking about gender and intentional civilian victimization Revisiting the narratives that began this introduction, it is possible to see gender influencing intentional civilian victimization in what happened to Hassan and Benedicte and their contemporaries. Referencing experiences like Benedicte's, Judith Gardam has explained that rape is never truly aimed at or affecting just one person (1993: 363). Instead, "rape functions as a strategy to deliver a blow against a collective energy by striking at a group of high symbolic value" (Pettman 1996: 190). By raping Benedicte, government forces were attacking non -lvoirians by attacking "their" women, as "xenophobic speech [was] aimed specifically at women from the 'enemy' community," encouraging rape and sexual violence (Amnesty International 2007). As a result, sexual violence became "an intentional strategy to terrorise, demean, and defeat an entire population, as well as a way of engendering hate and destruction" between the rebels and the government in Cote d'Ivoire (Amnesty International 2004). In the 1990s war in Bosnia-Herzegovina, women suffered the brunt of civilian victimization, as a result both of apparently gender -neutral tactics and of a systematic campaign of genocidal rape. Reports of mass rape began appearing in newspaper headlines in August of 1992 (Hansen 2001: 55). Women were raped, both individually and as proxy for the nation of Bosnia-Herzegovina also being 'raped.' The rape of civilian women was also the rape of ('their') nation, an idea that was reiterated by Bosnian ambassador to the United Nations addressing the Security Council in 1993: Excellencies, Bosnia and Herzegovina is being gang-raped ... I do not lightly apply the analogy of a gang rape to the plight of the Republic of Bosnia and Herzegovina. As we know, systematic rape has been one of the weapons of this aggression against the Bosnian women in particular. (Metrovic 1994: xii) In this statement the rape of Bosnian women is metaphor for the destruction and 'rape' of a nation, literally and figuratively. This sort of "rape happens, not as a consequence of thoughtless, provocative, or unfortunate behavior, but as a question of national warfare" (Hansen 2001: 59). Lene Hansen explains that, in Bosnia, [r ]aping "the nation's women" is not only an act of violence against individual women; it also works to install a disempowered masculinity as constitutive of the identities of the nation's men. The interconnection between individual/ collective and national/ gendered might also be illustrated by the way that a woman impregnated by rape can be represented as a passive "national" container of a child imagined to be the future bearer of the rapist's nationality. In this way, an individual rape can be read for its collective, national significance through the complex sign of the child's imagined future identity as an embodiment of the enemy state. (Hansen 2001: 60) Women were also targeted for violence that was not explicitly sexual. Some Serb policy statements emphasized depriving individual households of nutritional and medical resources necessary for reproduction as a way to target the opponent ethnicities. Even the targeting of men had gendered connotations and implications. Planning for the Srebrenica massacre (where an estimated 8,000 men were killed, selected as men for victimization), the killing was discussed as a strategy for reducing the availability of men, who were characterized as fertilizers and protectors for women. Planners referred to their strategies as "cleaning houses" such that women would pose "less resistance to repopulation" (referring to forced impregnation) without 'their' men. 7 Narratives like this could be and have been told of many wars, genocides, conflicts, and terrorist attacks around the world. In this book, we present evidence that when belligerents intentionally victimize civilians, they are actually attacking women because of women's actual and symbolic position in the life, livelihood, and nationalist narratives of the opponent's state and/ or nation. While most people who read Benedicte and Hasan's stories assume that Benedicte's experience was a gendered form of civilian victimization and Hasan's experience was tragic but a case of 'normal' or ungendered civilian victimization, we argue that it is not just in sexual violence against civilians that civilian victimization is gendered. Instead, when civilians are attacked in war, often 'civilian' is in important ways a proxy for women, not as female bodies but for how they are positioned in and symbolic of nation and state. Wartime sexual violence is {like other civilian victimization tactics) a way to get to the 'heart' of the opponent by destroying both crucial resources and the very parts of their society which legitimate the fighting of the war in the first place - pure, innocent women that good men fight just wars to protect (see, e.g., Elshtain 1987). Along these lines, we theorize intentional civilian victimization through gender lenses. Expanding on feminist work about nationalism and war generally, and the noncombatant immunity principle specifically, we contend that the very same logic that makes belligerents so eager to 'protect' their innocent women from wars also encourages them to attack the women who are seen as belonging to their enemies. In war stories, just warriors fight the good fight to protect their innocent women and children from those foreign or outside men who would attack them (Huston 1983). Just warriors, then, legitimate not only wars generally but also their masculinities specifically by protecting women back home (Sjoberg 2006b). Attacking the women that motivate the opponent to fight - the women that symbolize his state and/ or nation and whose protection legitimates his war - attacks both the will to fight a particular war and the logic of war-fighting. In these terms, as we will discuss in more detail in Chapter 3, intentional civilian victimization can be seen as a product of the gendered narratives that legitimate and sustain nationhood and the practices of the making and fighting of wars. We are, of course, not arguing that women and only women are killed in the victimization of civilians. Such an argument would be both inaccurate and oversimplified. We are instead arguing that 'civilian victimization' is, sometimes consciously and sometimes not, an attack on women, where 'civilian' is in important ways a proxy for women. But this proxy is not a simple, one-to-one mapping where belligerents think 'civilian' but mean 'women' (as women), even to the extent that belligerents are willing to admit attacking civilians. Rather the proxy is a complex indicator of state/nation, based on actual and perceived strength. Belligerents attack (women) civilians for the same reason they claim protection for their own - because the 'protection racket' is an underlying justification for states, governments, and their wars (see, e.g., S. Peterson 1977). Insomuch as women are indicators, signifiers, and reproducers of state and nation, belligerents attack women to attack the state and nation. We contend that such an explanation, when compared to the others that have been presented up to this point, provides both greater theoretical leverage towards understanding the problem of civilian targeting and greater empirical explanatory power for the particulars of cases of civilian victimization in war. In the remainder of this introduction, we outline how this book makes that argument and presents both quantitative and qualitative empirical evidence to support it.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.