UBI solves better than an FJG, addressing the causes of women’s issues.
Kathryn Karcher 2019 – Former President of California Academy of Appellate Lawyers, Certified Specialist in Appellate Law
“How Might a Universal Basic Income or Federal Jobs Guarantee Help Women?”, Political Science Honors Program, 03/04/2019, https://digital.lib.washington.edu/researchworks/bitstream/handle/1773/43803/LRA2019_Karcher.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y – A.K.
When it comes to more easily predictable and thus escapable violence, a full-time job may not be the most accessible exit option for some women. Women who face more burdens when it comes to entering a workplace, due to complications such as caregiving responsibilities or disabilities, may be less able to rely on a jobs program. However, this could be accounted for with full-time childcare or forms of employment which include people with different abilities. Still, neither UBI nor FJG address the causes of violence, so they both do a fair job of addressing this face of oppression.
Conclusions: Based on this analysis of UBI and FJG, each policy’s respective ability to undermine the faces of oppression largely depends on the precise terms of policy that are ultimately implemented. Upon a closer look at the logic underpinning them, it appears that UBI would do a better job at confronting the faces of oppression that affect women. FJG’s downside is that it may exacerbate marginalization and exploitation, and it does not do a particularly good job of undermining any of the root causes of women’s oppression. UBI, on the other hand, does not exacerbate any of the faces and directly combats the causes of women’s marginalization and cultural imperialism. Overall, UBI is more closely aligned with the social justice framework and would do more for women than FJG.