Other social assistance programs won’t need as much funding in the aff world. Also, poverty costs more.
Kathryn Karcher 2019 – Former President of California Academy of Appellate Lawyers, Certified Specialist in Appellate Law “How Might a Universal Basic Income or Federal Jobs Guarantee Help Women?”, Political Science Honors Program, 03/04/2019, https://digital.lib.washington.edu/researchworks/bitstream/handle/1773/43803/LRA2019_Karcher.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y – A.K.
Decreased costs in other programs and increased and new taxes could offset these totals. Progressives should be cautious about cutting social programs, particularly because this aspect of UBI can provide a trojan horse for those who wish to cut social programs that many Americans need. Still, both UBI and FJG would reduce the number of people who require additional assistance. Considering the fact that studies estimate $153 billion per year is spent on public assistance programs due to low wages, we can see that the benefits of UBI or FJG would reduce the costs of other programs. The Supplemental Assistance Nutrition Program (SNAP), the Children’s Health Insurance Program (CHIP), unemployment insurance, and TANF would require less funding once people had either a basic income or a well-paying job with benefits. Increased and new taxes on the financially well-off should precede any cuts to social programs. Carbon taxes, financial transaction taxes, and land-value taxes would distribute wealth more equitably without further burdening those in the lower and middle classes. An additional benefit of this approach is that increased taxes on corporations and eliminating subsidies to fossil fuel companies have the simultaneous effect of funding new social programs while helping the environment and redistributing wealth. Discussions of these costs must include the positive impact that UBI and FJG would likely have on Americans’ spending power and the labor market. A jobs guarantee, for instance, would employ approximately 10 million workers. When we consider the costs offset by UBI or FJG, along with new taxes that will make our tax system more fair, neither policy is so exceptionally expensive. Those who remain skeptical about whether these programs warrant these changes to our budget should consider the exorbitant cost of the status quo. Harry Holzer, a labor economist at Georgetown, “calculated that child poverty alone costs the United States about 4 percent of GDP a year, every year, by reducing productivity and work output, increasing the incidence of crime, and pushing up public health expenditures of children when they become adults. That adds up to roughly $700 billion a year, a little more than the United States spends on the military and a little less than it spends on Social Security.” Without even considering more pressing issues of justice, poverty is far more expensive than effective social programs.