Ethical obligation to reject paternalism – it relies on devaluation and manipulation of the individual.
Koepke 13 - Instructor at the Johns Hopkins University Center; MA in Philosophy from Georgia State University (Cami, Libertarian Paternalism and the Authority Of The Autonomous Person, ScholarWorks @ Georgia State University)
Groll emphasizes that the primary feature that makes paternalism impermissible with respect to competent adults is the practical reasoning of the paternalist actor (2012, p. 717). In particular, one of the reasons that the paternalist actor does not treat the will of a competent subject as structurally decisive in her considerations is that she thinks that the subject “fails to exercise [his] capacity for sound judgment” (p. 718). The reasoning that underlies the actions of Bob’s doctor and Ernest’s friend Sabina is that they think Bob and Ernest are failing to make a good self-regarding decision, or at least not as good a decision as Bob’s doctor and Ernest’s friend could make for them (2012, p. 718). Yet, whether Bob or Ernest make the optimal decision in self- regarding matters is their own business. Respecting the will of a competent adult means recognizing that the individual’s self-regarding decisions are hers, and hers alone, to make. Respecting the will involves making it the decisive consideration when deciding how to act toward that individual in matters regarding her well-being. While Groll (2012) does not explicitly discuss the S/T argument, his distinction between treating the will as structurally decisive and treating it as substantially decisive is useful for understanding why libertarian paternalism disrespects the will of individuals, even though it preserves choices and does not counter the preferences of individuals (2012, p. 692). If the government adopted the S/T argument for libertarian paternalism as a basis for policymaking, it would fail to accord the will of competent adults the respect it intuitively deserves. Sunstein and Thaler think that the will of competent adults should only be treated as substantially decisive in the government’s policy deliberations. In the government’s deliberation process, they make considerations of well-being to be of higher priority than considerations about the will; “The promotion of well-being should be a principal goal” of the government (2006, p. 253). This prioritization of considerations is especially apparent in Sunstein and Thaler’s reasons for preferring the default method of nudging over the mandated choice method. Recall that in the mandated choice method, an individual’s options are presented in a way that encourages her to deliberate about what choice is really the best for her, hopefully engaging her ability for careful judgment. In contrast, the default method is aimed at utilizing reasoning biases to increase the likelihood of an individual making a specific decision. Sunstein and Thaler favor the default method precisely because it is more likely to result in the individual selecting the optimal option. They write that if a certain option likely “promotes people’s welfare, perhaps [the default method] should be preferred over requiring active choices” (2006, p. 258). However, while mandated choices are intended to engage an individual’s abilities for deliberation and judgment, the default method attempts to skirt these abilities to achieve a specific outcome, i.e. the individual’s well-being. Rather than supporting a method intended to encourage individuals to deliberate about their options, Sunstein and Thaler prefer a method intended to manipulate reasoning biases in order to promote well-being.