Federal involvement in jobs backfires – ruins innovation and productivity.
Standing ’13 (Guy Standing, "Why A Basic Income Is Necessary For A Right To Work." Basic Income Studies 7:2. 2013. October 09, 2020. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/269594683_Why_a_Basic_lncome_ls_Nece ssary_for_a_Right_to_Work)
The economic system that came closest to giving every adult a "job guarantee" was the Soviet Union, which even regarded anybody not in employment as "parasitic". It is not a model that leaps to mind as one to be emulated. If everybody is guaranteed a job, it becomes extremely hard to dismiss anybody for tardiness or low productivity, and it discourages voluntary mobility, as well as putting a block on technological innovation. In a market economy, it is generally recognized by economists that some unemployment is necessary. Many economists believe that there is a "natural" rate of unemployment ground out by the structural characteristics of production and employment. Its closely related concept is the NAIRU, the "non-accelerating inflation rate of unemployment". One can dispute the methodology for conceiving and measuring these concepts but, at the very least, ever since the origin of the Phillips Curve in 1958, it has been accepted that if unemployment is pushed too low, inflationary pressures will become intense. If price rises and wage rises accelerate, economic problems multiply. In other words, guaranteeing everybody a job would create huge economic costs. That is not the end of the matter. If the government guaranteed everybody a job, how would that be translated into practical policy? Would the person not given a job to his or her liking be able to sue the government for compensation or for a job? What right of refusal would be allowed? Alexis de Tocqueville (1848) long ago put his finger on the ultimate dilemma, when he pointed out that guaranteeing every person the right to a job would mean either that the government would have to spread until it had taken over almost the entire economy (which he saw as communism) or it would be obliged to force employers to provide jobs and penalize them for not doing so (which he saw as socialism).