Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Combing UBI and JG is key – doubles the solvency.

Lu, 21 – Associate Professor of Law and Co-Director, Economic Justice Project, CUNY School of Law [Lynn D. Lu, “From Stigma to Dignity? Transforming Workfare with Universal Basic Income and a Federal Job Guarantee,” CUNY Academic Works, 2021, https://academicworks.cuny.edu/cl_pubs/344/, accessed 6-25-2023]

This Article examines reinvigorated proposals for universal basic income (UBI) and a federal job guarantee (JG), both of which seek to reduce poverty, income inequality, and the widening racial wealth gap.8 It assesses the potential these reforms have to put more money into the hands of those most likely to use it while also ending involuntary unemployment and boosting labor conditions for all—but especially Blacks and people of color with less access to generational wealth, higher education, and protection against employment discrimination.9 It concludes that both UBI and a JG are necessary, but each is insufficient on its own to achieve greater economic security and mobility with dignified work for all. Crucially, a universal minimum income untethered to any work requirement is essential to break the racialized and gendered stigma that conflates economic need with welfare dependency. Equally important is the guarantee of public employment at a living wage for those who voluntarily choose to avoid gaps in earned income and employment history but have historically been excluded from the best work-life options.10 Together, UBI and a JG form vital pillars of social support for withstanding potential crises— large or small—and creating a secure future. Part II of this Article describes the main features of UBI and JG proposals and canvasses the diverse range of concerns that have motivated policy makers past and present—some more explicitly focused on racial justice than others—to consider their adoption. Such concerns include simplification of bureaucracy, prevention of job loss, valuation of carework, reduction of stigma, and worker empowerment. Part II concludes that, even in times of deep political polarization, unprecedented economic inequality and concentration of wealth may create common ground for enacting UBI and JG reforms with enduring impact. Part III nonetheless identifies persistent ideological beliefs and societal assumptions about race, work, and personal responsibility that have limited the potential of even modest UBI and JG proposals in the past, either through political compromise and policy drift or due to logistical challenges on the ground. By examining lessons from income proposals and work programs in U.S. history dating from the New Deal era to welfare reform, Part III illustrates how concerns about cost; fraud; waste; and, most importantly, disincentives to work productively diluted the potential of such projects.11 Part IV analyzes contemporary examples of local UBI and JG reforms to highlight further opportunities for restoring the dignity of basic support and work choices through a combined federal UBI and JG. In particular, Part IV examines Argentina’s governmental Plan Jefes y Jefes de Hogares program as a move toward a JG; Stockton, California’s 2019 UBI program, funded through private donations solicited by then-mayor Michael Tubbs, as a promising pilot program; and New York City’s implementation of state constitutional mandates to provide aid and support to the needy within the constraints of federal workfare directives as an ongoing experiment that could lead to a robust voluntary jobs program with a broad social safety net. Finally, Part V proposes not a magic-bullet solution but a starting framework for effective implementation of UBI and JG programs that leverage federal tax administration and oversight while empowering community-based organizations to maximize public participation in program design. Part V also highlights the need for further research to identify reasonable and realistic steps toward transforming workfare with less stigma and greater dignity.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.