Explanation
You can understand this disadvantage as an “Inflation DA,” “Interest Rates DA,” or simply an “Economy DA.”
It argues that if the federal government pursues significant fiscal redistribution it would lead to the Federal Reserve (aka “The Fed”) raising interest rates to combat the real or perceived inflation that results from plan.
The uniqueness is pretty good because the while inflation has been high for a while, the Fed recently paused rate hikes and signaled that inflation is cooling off. The economy is avoiding a recession and we’re recovering from many of the supply issues from Covid. Growth might be slow, but the Fed is ensuring a soft transition.
The link should be massive. A federal jobs guarantee would cost hundreds of billions of dollars in new fiscal spending, but it would also cause wage inflation (functionally raise the minimum wage to $15/hour). Any UBI would require massive spending and give everyone a lot more money to spend, causing a huge increase in aggregate demand throughout the economy. You do have to be careful about the way the aff funds the plan (tax increases vs deficit spending), but the effect of the plan would be inflationary regardless. \
The impact debate is multifaceted and lethal because you can argue that it turns the aff and has external impacts. Choose either the warming or the developing economies impact for your 1nc (ideally you pick an impact that’s not claimed in the 1ac). Both impacts deal directly with raising interest rates (you don’t have to win actual inflation) and identify broader consequences outside the US economy. Still, the most important part of the impact debate will be turning the aff. You need to argue that inflation hurts the economy, causes slow growth, produces inequality and poverty, etc.
For affirmative answers, I’d focus on long-term and inevitable economic issues. On the uniqueness side, the Fed is probably still going to eventually raise interest rates in the future. On the impact side, the aff should be able to win that the current system (which produces inequality, poverty, etc.) is unsustainable.
To get great at this DA you need to know a lot of theory and be comfortable with different terms (think AP Econ). Luckily there are a lot of youtube videos out there and I’d recommend the Investopedia as a go-to website for short readings on each topic.
Good luck!