High employment doesn’t cause inflation
Pavlina Tcherneva, June 2020, Tcherneva is an American economist, of Bulgarian descent, working as associate professor and director of the Economics program at Bard College. She is also a research associate at the Levy Economics Institute and expert at the Institute for New Economic Thinking, Kindle Edition. The Case for a Job Guarantee (1st ed.). Wiley. Retrieved from https://www.perlego.com/book/1504079/the-case-for-a-job-guarantee-pdf (Original work published 2020)
And yet economists regularly talk about unemployment in these terms – as something that is not only inevitable, but also necessary for the smooth functioning of the economy – and formulate policies on the premise that there is a “natural” level of unemployment. This was succinctly put by Federal Reserve Chairman Jerome Powell in January 2019: “We need the concept of a natural rate of unemployment. We need to have some sense of whether unemployment is high, low, or just right.”1 What is the “right” number of people who are struggling to find paid work? Many economists fear that if unemployment is “too low” and labor markets are “too tight” then firms will have to raise wages to attract workers and in turn raise prices to recover those costs. Low unemployment, the argument goes, could cause high or even accelerating inflation, producing one of the clunkiest concepts in economics – the Non-Accelerating Inflation Rate of Unemployment (NAIRU). Inflation-fighting central banks then aim to finetune the economy around the NAIRU.2 Countless think tanks, academics, and government institutions spend valuable resources on trying to identify this elusive “optimal level” of unemployment, while the actual number of unemployed people yo-yos around as the economy grows and slows down. The Congressional Budget Office (CBO) has maintained that the “natural level” throughout the postwar era was between 4.5 and 6.5 percent, and yet here we are today with official unemployment at 3.5 percent. It is no consolation that Chairman Powell recently admitted, under oath, that the unemployment–inflation relationship has collapsed.3 The search for the NAIRU continues. Top economists vigorously defend it and the Fed’s explicit objective is to manage inflation by slowing down the rate of investment and hiring when unemployment gets “too low.”4 The trouble with this fine-tuning approach is threefold. First, the NAIRU is a myth.5 Economists (and the Fed) cannot figure out the nature of the unemployment–inflation relationship, nor whether it is even a causal one.6 Second, on its own admission, the Fed has no reliable theory of inflation either.7 Third, despite failing to pin down the NAIRU or the inflation target, Fed officials have been insisting at least since 2014 that the economy has reached full employment. Many will remember a similar experience in the 1990s, when experts kept warning that the economy has reached maximum employment, even as the unemployment rate kept breaking through every new official NAIRU estimate, with no accelerating inflation in sight. And like a scene from Groundhog Day, with NAIRU warnings on repeat, the unemployed people are caught in a jobless trap with no way out. This problem is worse around the world. In 2012, the Annual Economic Forecast of the European Commission claimed that the natural rate of unemployment in Spain was 26.6 percent – the economy simply could not do better. Tcherneva, Pavlina R.. The Case for a Job Guarantee (pp. 25-26). Wiley. Kindle Edition.