Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

No warming impact.

O’Brien 19---Anthony Patrick O'Brien is a professor of economics at Lehigh University. He received his Ph. D. from the University of California, Berkeley, October 19th ("Your View by Lehigh professor: ‘Climate change is not going to kill us’", Morning Call, Available online at https://www.mcall.com/opinion/mc-opi-climate-change-existential-threat-20191019-kdluxxt45vfdhkfavdppz2yjaa-story.html, Accessed 4-29-2021)

Do scientists agree with Zach? The federal government’s Fourth National Climate Assessment was released last November. Hundreds of scientists from 13 government agencies compiled the 1,500-page report. It finds no existential threat from climate change. Zach is likely to have a long life. The report concludes that by 2090, under a worst-case scenario, the U.S. economy will suffer $507 billion in annual losses from climate change. Sounds like a big number, but it’s less than 1% of gross domestic product in that year. To make the U.S. economy carbon free, Bernie Sanders has proposed spending $16 trillion, or more than 30 times the annual damage climate change is likely to cause. Some scientists take issue with the National Climate Assessment and argue that the cost of climate change will eventually run into the trillions of dollars. They could be right, but there are three reasons to question any long-range forecast of the climate (or the economy, or anything else): 1) the unavoidable imprecision in the models used; 2) the neglect of market adjustments; and 3) the neglect of technological change. First, if you’ll pardon a little geek speak, the world is nonlinear (straight-line projections don’t work) and stochastic (or uncertain). So assumptions about initial conditions and the estimated parameters of models matter a lot. Years ago, economist Paul Samuelson of MIT showed that in building nonlinear models of the business cycle, small changes in a model’s parameters would result in forecasts that the economy would either grow smoothly with mild recessions (great) or would experience increasingly severe recessions (uh-oh). Edward Lorenz, also of MIT, applied similar reasoning to climate models, concluding: “In view of the inevitable inaccuracy and incompleteness of weather observations, precise very long-range forecasting would seem to be non-existent.” These insights into the nature of nonlinear, stochastic models became the foundation for a branch of math called chaos theory. In short, there are good reasons that economists can’t accurately forecast when the next recession will begin and meteorologists can’t accurately forecast whether the coming winter will be snowy or dry. And the further in the future the forecast, the more skeptical you should be. Forecasts of conditions 70 years in the future? Whether rosy or gloomy, there’s no good reason to believe them. Models of climate change also ignore the role of the market adjustments that are already occurring. Consumers worried about climate change have been eating less beef, buying more products made from recycled materials, and buying more from companies that are operating in an environmentally friendly way. As always in a market system, companies are more than happy to adapt to changing consumer preferences. Finally, the National Climate Assessment and similar forecasts assume essentially no technological progress in energy efficiency, sequestering carbon or other ways of lessening climate change. No technological progress over 70 years in an area attracting as much research attention from business, government and universities as climate change does? Not likely.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.