Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

U.S. public health is a patchwork system-lack of consistency between state and local levels.

Wallace and Sharfstein ‘22

Megan Wallace and Joshua M. Sharfstein, 2022, Dr.P.H. and M.D, “The Patchwork U.S. Public Health System,” New England Journal of Medicine, 6 January 2022, , @KK

The response to foodborne illness — a quintessential public health activity — is a microcosm of the uneven patchwork that characterizes all of U.S. public health. In the shadow of a pandemic, understanding this haphazard architecture is a step toward appreciating the U.S. paradox of enormous health expenditures but poor outcomes for population health. To begin with, there is no clear administrative structure that organizes the many federal agencies involved in public health (see table). Twenty-one major federal agencies have a role in pandemic preparedness and response, for example, and more than 100 federal offices have been engaged in work during the Covid-19 pandemic. At the state and local levels, variation is the rule, not the exception. Twenty-nine state health departments stand alone, and the others are part of larger health and human services agencies. About half of states have a board of health to provide guidance for public health activities; in the other half, no such board exists. About two thirds of state health officials are appointed by the governor, and the other third are appointed by the secretary of the larger human services agency, a state public health board, or some other entity. Similarly, there is little consistency in the relationships between state and local health departments. In 7 states, the state health department operates all local health offices; in 30 states, local health departments operate largely without state control; and in the remainder, various amounts of collaboration occur. A 2012 review noted the challenge of classification: “Even in states that are considered centralized, it is not uncommon for local government entities to exhibit some authority; likewise, in some decentralized states, state government has some powers regarding the local health unit.”2 There are about 2800 local health departments in the United States, most of which serve fewer than 50,000 people. About half of local health departments report to a local board of health, which may be an elected body such as a county council or an independently appointed group. Another 20% work with the local board of health in an advisory capacity. The activities undertaken by health departments also vary. In 1994, the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services convened the Core Public Health Functions Steering Committee to define the 10 Essential Public Health Services, a list that was recently updated by a coalition of public health groups (see box) to center equity and include addressing structural causes of poor health, including poverty, racism, and gender discrimination. The federal agencies and state health departments have broad responsibilities, but typically, local health departments perform less than half of vital public health activities.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.