Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The plan is key to redistribute wealth, eliminate income inequality, and guarantee health access for everyone.

Rudiger 16 – Anja Rudiger, Ph.D. in Political Theory from the University of Kiel, former Director of Programs at the National Economic & Social Rights Initiative (“Human Rights and the Political Economy of Universal Health Care,” Health and Human Rights, Vol. 18, No. 2, pgs. 67-78, https://www.hhrjournal.org/2016/12/human-rights-and-the-political-economy-of-universal-health-care-designing-equitable-financing/)

Health system financing is a critical factor in securing universal health care and achieving equity in access and payment. The human rights framework offers valuable guidance for designing a financing strategy that meets these goals. This article presents a rights-based approach to health care financing developed by the human right to health care movement in the United States. Grounded in a human rights analysis of private, market-based health insurance, advocates make the case for public financing through progressive taxation. Financing mechanisms are measured against the twin goals of guaranteeing access to care and advancing economic equity. The added focus on the redistributive potential of health care financing recasts health reform as an economic policy intervention that can help fulfill broader economic and social rights obligations. Based on a review of recent universal health care reform efforts in the state of Vermont, this article reports on a rights-based public financing plan and model, which includes a new business tax directed against wage disparities. The modeling results suggest that a health system financed through equitable taxation could produce significant redistributive effects, thus increasing economic equity while generating sufficient funds to provide comprehensive health care as a universal public good. Introduction Universal health care is about more than our health—it is also a prescription for economic transformation, budget and tax reform, and public sector strengthening. It can catalyze economic redistribution in countries with fragmented market-based health systems, and resist austerity and privatization policies where universal systems already exist. If the human rights framework is to have a role in shaping this high-stakes political project, the right to health care has to be turned into a conceptual tool to guide systems change. Health systems goals put forward at the international, national, or sub-national level are not usually measured against human rights standards, and the policy instruments that implement reforms are not assessed for their consistency with the right to health care. In policy terms, universal health care is decidedly under-defined, which opens up space for periodic re-framing efforts based on evolving political contexts and interests, as the transition from the Alma-Ata Declaration’s Health For All to universal health coverage (UHC) illustrates.1 There is a lack of rights-based policy guidance to assess this shift from “care” to “coverage” and its apparent preference for an insurance business model over public service provision. To guide debates about the political economy of universal health care and inform the design of universal systems, it is incumbent on human rights advocates to establish the right to health care as a workable policy tool and engage with policymaking beyond general statements of values or legal defenses of individual rights. Right to health advocates must be able to define both the goals of a health system and the instruments and mechanisms conducive to achieving those goals. A rights-based framework of policy-relevant principles and standards for health system design, and particularly for financing, is needed to set parameters for modeling, implementing, and improving universal health care systems. This article presents a human rights approach to financing health care, along with the design of a financing mechanism for a sub-national universal system in the United States, including a predictive model simulating equitable revenue generation. This work, developed—with the author’s involvement—by the Vermont Workers’ Center’s (VWC) Healthcare Is a Human Right campaign (HCHR) between 2008 and 2015, includes a system assessment tool that evolved from a rights-based analytical framework designed to evaluate the most recent round of federal health care reform in the United States.2 Although grounded in international legal human rights norms, the example presented here does not make a legal case but offers a normative policy framework, informed by economic analysis and empirical data. All tools were developed collaboratively, with community participation, to advance grassroots human rights campaigns and foster the broad movement building—the coordinated developmental process that creates, strengthens, and sustains social movement infrastructure, membership and strategy—that is required to amass the political power necessary to effect systemic transformation. Human Rights and the US health care market Over the last decade, rights-based advocacy for universal, publicly financed health care has been gaining traction in the United States, notwithstanding the century-old resistance of industry interests and the failure of the recent federal reform, the Affordable Care Act (ACA), to challenge those interests.3 Although the ACA expanded access to the public Medicaid program, its mandate on individuals to purchase private insurance policies served to channel customers—and public subsidies—to the insurance industry, thus consolidating the private insurance market. While many health advocates responded with plans for improving the ACA, human rights campaigners pointed to the structural inequity of market-based health insurance and redoubled their organizing for a public health care system. The growing movement for the right to health care is best reflected in the Healthcare Is a Human Right Campaign Collaborative, a national movement building initiative inspired by the success of the eponymous campaign in Vermont, which became the first US state to enact a universal health care law and attempt a transition to a publicly financed universal system.4 The focus on health care financing by both policy makers and campaigners has its roots in the particular nature of the US health care crisis. In the only affluent country without a universal health system, the abundance of resources invalidates any argument for a progressive realization of human rights. Health care funding is plentiful (17% GDP in 2013), yet the mechanisms for raising and allocating those funds are deeply inequitable.5 While total health expenditure is twice as high as in most European countries, health disparities abound and outcomes are poor, with up to 100,000 deaths annually considered amenable to health care.6 Financial barriers are a key predictor of poor access to and quality of health care (oftentimes correlated with structural racism) and a leading cause of debt and impoverishment. The private, market-based insurance system does not function as an effective pre-payment mechanism, even with the public subsidies introduced by the ACA. Because of substantial user fees at the point of service, insurance coverage fails to correlate sufficiently with either improved access to care or ability to pay.7 Low-income people with private insurance rather than public (Medicaid, Medicare, or military) not only spend more of their income on health care than the wealthy, they are also more likely to have lower value insurance plans and delay or avoid getting needed care.8 It follows that universal health care advocacy is centered on promoting redistributive health care financing that facilitates both universal, equitable access to care and equity in the payment for care. Advocates have turned to human rights principles to inform the analysis and development of health-related economic and fiscal policies. The right to health care has been configured as a tool for shaping decisions about equity and resource redistribution.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.