Medicaid redistributes wealth by allowing more people to put less money into healthcare and more into other assets.
Jackson et al. 21 (Margot Jackson, Associate Professor of Society, “The Effects of State-Level Medicaid Coverage on Family Wealth”, RSF, August 2021, https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10284574/) -JCG
Medicaid access could be associated with family wealth in several ways. First, increased coverage may be positively associated with households’ wealth by freeing up funds that would otherwise be used for medical expenses, better enabling families to save money or purchase assets. This possibility may have become more likely after the OBRA86 expansion, when the vast majority of states ended their previous use of asset testing for determining Medicaid eligibility. Previously, Medicaid eligibility for pregnant women and infants had been tied to their AFDC eligibility, which involved asset testing to qualify. The asset test allowed “a home of any value, an automobile worth up to $1,500, and any other real or personal property essential for day-to-day living worth up to $1,000” (Government Accountability Office 1987, 18). Income and asset limits for Supplemental Security Income (SSI), Medicaid through SSI eligibility, and those for the medically needy program were higher (Government Accountability Office 1987). In addition to expanding access based on income limits, OBRA86 also provided states with options to simplify the Medicaid eligibility process for pregnant women and infants. For example, states shortened application forms, out-stationed eligibility workers at provider sites, and expedited maternity-related applications (National Governors’ Association 1990, 3). States also dropped the asset test required for Medicaid eligibility among pregnant women and infants. In 1990, “44 states no longer review clients’ assets when determining eligibility for pregnant women and children” (National Governors’ Association 1990, 3). The seven states that retained the asset test were California, Colorado, Illinois, Iowa, Missouri, North Dakota, and Texas. Additional states dropped the test over time: Colorado and Missouri by July 1990 and Illinois and Texas by July 1991. Beginning in 1992, some states (Nevada, Utah, and Arkansas) began reinstating asset tests for Medicaid eligibility among pregnant women or children (National Governors’ Association 1992).
The elimination of asset testing as a condition for Medicaid enrollment among pregnant women and young children increased the possibility for participating families to build wealth. Greater access to Medicaid for low- and middle-income families may reduce the amount these families spend on out-of-pocket medical expenses, private insurance premiums, expensive copayments, or other directly purchased services. Although many pregnant women and young children who became eligible for Medicaid with the expansions were uninsured, more than a third were covered under private insurance plans (Cutler and Gruber 1996; Dubay and Kenney 1997), which typically have higher out-of-pocket costs for premiums and copayments. The ability to substitute public insurance for private insurance may therefore free up economic resources for some families, enabling them to save money or to purchase assets such as a home.
Among families who were uninsured, public insurance may also replace some degree of private spending. Research concerning the effects of Medicaid on consumption in the broader adult population demonstrates that increases in Medicaid access are associated with increases in spending on nondurable goods (Gruber and Yelowitz 1999), and that switching from private to public health insurance reduces spending on out-of-pocket medical care and health insurance costs (Shaefer, Grogan, and Pollak 2011). Among families with children, a study on the effects of State Children’s Health Insurance Program (SCHIP, later CHIP) expansions in the late 1990s, which were targeted toward higher income families than the Medicaid expansions, shows that SCHIP coverage increases savings behavior among households with children (Leininger, Levy, and Schanzenbach 2010). Evidence on the effects of Medicaid expansions on the wealth of families with children is lacking, however.
Increases in Medicaid access may also reduce the debt held by families with children, both by reducing medical debt and by improving their ability to pay down existing debts from credit cards and other sources. Although surprisingly little research examines the effects of Medicaid on debt, evidence among adults suggests that Medicaid coverage reduces the likelihood of personal bankruptcy, as well as the prevalence of “medical divorces” intended to protect the assets of a healthy spouse when the other spouse has substantial medical bills (Gross and Notowidigdo 2011; Slusky and Ginther 2017). Results from an experimental Medicaid expansion program in Oregon demonstrate that Medicaid access significantly reduced the frequency of missed bill payments because of medical expenses (Finkelstein et al. 2012). In addition, research on the recent Medicaid expansion under the Affordable Care Act demonstrates that increased Medicaid access reduces the number of unpaid bills and the amount of debt sent to collection agencies (Hu et al. 2018; Miller and Wherry 2019). However, these studies focus on the broader Medicaideligible population and not on families with children.