Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Private equity firms rarely deliver on their promises—their returns are overstated.

Celarier ‘21

(Michelle Celarier, award-winning journalist who writes about the world of money and power, “Is Private Equity Overrated?,” The New York Times, December 6, 2021, https://www.nytimes.com/2021/12/04/business/is-private-equity-overrated.html)-ERL

But private equity’s returns increasingly may not provide the stellar performance that investors have been sold — and the returns can be misleadingly calculated in a way that overstates success. As of September 2020, private equity funds had produced a 14.2 percent median annualized return, net of fees, over the previous 10 years, compared with 13.7 percent for the S&P 500, according to an analysis of indexes by the American Investment Council, a lobbying group for the industry, using the latest numbers offered. Public pension funds invested in private equity actually had worse returns than from the S&P 500 — 12.8 percent, net of fees. (These returns, and others quoted in this article, do not include venture capital, which is typically viewed as a separate asset class.) Private equity firms have long engaged in contentious practices, including loading companies with debt and laying off workers. And calls for more transparency have arisen in Congress and the Securities and Exchange Commission. In October, Senator Elizabeth Warren, the Massachusetts Democrat who is one of Capitol Hill’s most vocal critics of private equity, reintroduced legislation that would, among other things, require more disclosure of returns and fees by private equity funds. The S.E.C. chair, Gary Gensler, has said the agency is taking a look at the same issues. Regardless, private equity is sitting on a mountain of cash. At the end of the first quarter this year, U.S. private equity funds had $841 billion in so-called dry powder, or money that was still to be invested, according to PitchBook. The deluge of dollars, which has continued apace in 2021, might be enough to make returns harder to come by. “Private equity is still outperforming public equity, but this outperformance is narrowing as all markets benefit from nonstop monetary and fiscal stimulus, and as private acquisition multiples rise,” Michael Cembalest, the chairman of market and investment strategy at J.P. Morgan Asset Management, wrote in a report this summer. Since 2009, Mr. Cembalest said in an interview, the median annual outperformance of private equity buyout funds has been “bouncing around on a median and average basis from 1 to 5 percent.” That’s down from around 15 percent in outperformance 20 years ago, according to his report, which also shows that private equity returns peaked in the early 1990s. “Since the financial crisis the industry has had a tougher time outperforming public equity benchmarks,” Mr. Cembalest noted. He also asked if today’s returns were high enough “given the illiquidity of private equity.” Ludovic Phalippou, a professor of finance at Oxford’s Said Business School, came to a harsher conclusion in a 2020 research paper that looked at North American private equity performance for funds launched between 2006 and 2015. It found that investors could have done just about as well with a stock index fund during that period, while the fees paid to private equity firms came to at least $230 billion, enabling the number of private equity multibillionaires to jump to 22 in 2020 from three in 2005. “The big picture is that they’re getting a lot of money for what they’re doing, and they’re not delivering what they have promised or what they pretend they’re delivering,” Mr. Phalippou said in an interview.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.