Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Single-Payer healthcare decreases expenditures overall.

Himmelstein and Woolhandler ’20

(David U. Himmelstein and Steffie Woolhandler, distinguished professor of public health and health policy and a lecturer at Harvard, “Single-Payer Reform: Heed the Evidence, Not the Soothsayers,” American Journal of Public Health, no. 4, April 1, 2020, -ERL

Even the most ambitious proposed tweaks to the ACA would leave millions uninsured or saddled with unaffordable copayments and deductibles. By contrast, single-payer systems have a track record of success. Until Canada implemented its single-payer reform, its health care financing and delivery systems mirrored those of the United States, health costs were virtually identical, and Canada trailed in life expectancy and infant mortality. Soon thereafter Canada pulled ahead on health outcomes and fell behind on expenditures. Today, Canada’s life expectancy is 3.4 years longer, its infant mortality rate 22% lower (https://bit.ly/2rVObD0), and its income-based health inequities2 are far smaller than ours. In conditions whose outcomes closely track care quality, such as type-1 diabetes, end-stage renal disease, and cystic fibrosis,3 Canadians fare better. Canada produces these superior outcomes at spectacularly lower costs: a difference of $6198 per capita in 2018. US private insurers’ overhead siphons $243.8 billion (13.2% of premiums) from patient care. Canadian private insurers—and those in Europe4—are similarly inefficient, but they play a miniscule role in those nations’ health systems. Meanwhile, the public Medicare programs in both nations (Canada’s single-payer system is also known as Medicare) subsist on 2% overhead. The United States wastes even more—$401 billion in 20175—on providers’ billing-related bureaucracy. Hospitals spend billions attributing costs and charges to individual patients, visits, and procedures and fighting with insurers to extract payment. Reliance on operating profits (labeled “surpluses” at nonprofit institutions) to fund the equipment purchases and renovations essential to survival drives CEOs to fritter away additional billions on upcoding, tailoring services to profitability, marketing to recruit profitable patients and demarketing to avoid unprofitable ones, and the other entrepreneurial exertions needed to generate profits and surpluses. A single-payer system could pay each hospital a lump sum to cover its operations with new buildings and major equipment financed through targeted grants rather than operating profits and surpluses—just as we fund public schools, fire departments, and health departments. In Canada and Scotland, this lump sum noncommercial payment strategy has kept hospital administrative costs at 12% of revenues, versus 25% in the United States. A single-payer reform would also spare doctors (and other practitioners) the expense and aggravation of negotiating contracts with payers and navigating varying billing and prior-approval requirements, referral networks, and formularies. The $600 billion in savings attainable through single-payer reform could be repurposed to make universal, first-dollar coverage affordable. Most single-payer cost estimates foresee modest initial cost reductions, with mounting savings thereafter (https://bit.ly/2O6d46X).

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.