Single-payer healthcare is the first step away from capitalism.
Waitzkin 18 [Howard Waitzkin is part of an international network of health workers, activists, and thinkers dedicated to helping provide a "good life" for those requiring health care services and social conditions that determine good health, “HEALTH CARE under the KNIFE Moving Beyond Capitalism for Our Health,” Monthly Review Press, 2018, https://academic.oup.com/sf/article-abstract/98/4/1/5528220?redirectedFrom=fulltext] WC
In the United States, the road ahead will involve intensified organizing to achieve the single-payer model of a national health program, a model that aims to provide universal access to care and to control costs by drastically reducing or eliminating administrative waste, profiteering, and corporate control. Adam Gaffney, David Himmelstein, and Steffie Woolhander in the next chapter present the most recent revision of the single-payer proposal developed by Physicians for a National Health Program during the late 1980s and most recently published during May 2016 in the American Journal of Public Health. Versions of this proposal have been introduced into the Senate by Bernie Sanders and the House of Representatives by John Conyers, with more than a hundred congressional co-sponsors. Adam, David, and Steffie, lead authors of the revised PNHP proposal, first analyze the three main ways that the interests of capital have encroached on U.S. health care during the decades since the original PNHP proposal: 1) the rise of for-profit managed care organizations (MCOs), 2) the emergence of high-deductible (“consumer-directed”) health insurance, and 3) the entrenchment of corporate ownership. They offer a critique of Obamacare, explaining and demystifying such innovations as Accountable Care Organizations, the consolidation and integration of health systems, and increasing share of costs for patients. The authors then summarize the key elements of the revised single-payer proposal, including its provisions about coverage, financing, and transition from the current corporatized and financialized arrangements, and comment on shifts in needed strategy during the era of Trump. Improved medical care for physical illnesses remains an incomplete goal if it does not encompass a holistic vision of health that includes improved mental health as well. But what are the prospects for mental health during this waning phase of the world capitalist system? Updating and refining a perspective previously developed by Erich Fromm, Carl Ratner, a cultural psychologist and activist who has written widely on mental health under capitalism, mental health innovations in other countries, and cooperatives as an incompletely realized model for progressive organizational change, argues that mental health under capitalism entails “pathological normalcy.” Seen through this lens, the day- to-day economic insecurities, violence, and lack of social solidarity experienced in capitalist society generate a kind of false consciousness, in which disordered mental processes become a necessary facet of survival, and emotional health becomes a deviant and marginalized condition. Carl dissects the well-known crises of our age in terms of the pathologies that have become seen as normal conditions of life: a normally polluted natural environment, a normally corrupt political system, a normally unequal hierarchy of social stratification, a normally unjust criminal justice system, normally violent living conditions due to the marketing of guns, normally dangerous working conditions, and so forth. Thus “pathologically normal economic practices—the daily manipulation, cheating, speculation, de- skilling, outsourcing, tax code revisions, and exploitation—are more destructive than the criminal thief.” Reckoning the implications for the road ahead, Carl argues that the struggle for improved mental health conditions cannot limit itself to reforms in the delivery of services but must entail a struggle to change the economic, political, and social underpinnings of pathological normalcy. Despite our own and others’ efforts to improve access to health and mental health services, we recognize that such services are not the main determinants of health and mental health outcomes. As Carles Muntaner and evolutionary biologist Rob Wallace, who has done extensive research focusing on the impact of capitalist agriculture on infections, especially epidemics such as influenza, Ebola, and Zika, show in their chapter, social and environmental conditions have become more important determinants of health than access to care, and such broader conditions explain the greatest part of the variation in health outcomes. Concerning social determinants, Carles in prior work has focused on social class and has considered differing conceptualizations of class. He has shown the advantage of a theoretical and empirical definition of social class rooted in relations of economic production, as opposed to the more commonly used demographic indicators of inequality such as income, education, and prestige. The latter indicators impede clarity of understanding about the conditions that separate the 1 percent from the 99 percent; they also mystify needed directions of political change through the notion that adjusting “disparities” in income can produce more favorable health and mental health outcomes. The authors emphasize struggles that directly confront social determinants through changes in broad societal policies. They also analyze some of the key environmental determinants of health, including unsafe water (citing the egregious example of Flint, Michigan), capitalist agribusiness practices, and deforestation in addition to climate change. They refer especially to the impact of these environmental determinants on emergent and re-emergent infectious diseases like Ebola, Zika, and yellow fever. To conclude the book, Adam Gaffney and I try to tackle the inevitable question of “what is to be done.” First, let me express my delight to collaborate with Adam. While I and several other authors of this book are closer to the end of our work lives than the beginning, Adam is much closer to the beginning. As a physician, historian, and activist (among other things), Adam is one of an emerging cadre of young people who will carry forth this struggle in future years, and their brilliance and audacity in doing so give us much hope. In our conclusion, we recognize at the outset that we hold no corner on strategic truth, given the complexities and challenges of current realities. Still, we see four main priorities for action in the United States and in other countries still affected by the neoliberal, corporatized, and commodified model of health care during the era of Trump: 1) a sustained, broad-based movement for a single-payer national health program that assures universal access to care and drastically reduces the role of corporations and private profit; 2) an activated labor movement that this time includes a well-organized sub-movement of health professionals such as physicians, whose deteriorated social-class position and proletarianized conditions of medical practice have made them ripe for activism and change; 3) more emphasis on local and regional organizing at the level of communal organizations as envisioned by István Mészáros and attempted in multiple countries as a central component in the revolutionary process of moving “beyond capital”;7 and 4) carefully confronting the role of political parties while recognizing the importance of labor or otherwise leftist parties in every country that has constructed a national health program, and understanding that the importance of party building goes far beyond electoral campaigns to more fundamental social transformation. All these priorities emphasize the urgency of creating bridges that link health activism with social movements that focus on social-class oppression, including poverty and inequality, racism, sexism, environmental degradation, militarism and imperialism, and the dominant ideologies that lead women and men to accept pathological social conditions as normal. With these contributions by leading scholars and activists based in several countries, our book tries to answer key and previously unresolved questions and to offer some guidance on strategy and political action in the years ahead. Through this work, we aim to inform future struggles for the transformation of capitalist societies, as well as the progressive reconstruction of health services and public health systems in the post- capitalist world. At roughly the same stage in my work life as Adam’s now, I asked (with a colleague), “Is a humane health care system possible in a capitalist society?” My focus then, as it remains today, involved “the exploitation of illness in capitalist society” and the “forms of social organization which foster this exploitation.”8 As the contradictions and weaknesses of global capitalism grow more profound and as the need for revolutionary transformation becomes clearer and more urgent, a non-exploitative health care system has entered the realm of the imaginable and the possible. The road leading to that place, for all its challenges, must become the road that travels “beyond capital” and beyond capitalism.