New tech won’t replace jobs- it complements work instead of replacing it and increases the value of non-automated work
Lincicome 2023
Scott Lincicome is the director of general economics and . He writes on international and domestic economic issues, including international trade; subsidies and industrial policy; manufacturing and global supply chains; and economic dynamism.; AI Is coming for Our Jobs (and That’s Okay); Februrary 8,2023; CATO; https://www.cato.org/commentary/ai-coming-our-jobs-thats-okay
Instead, humans—and markets—adjust in two ways .First, we learn to use whatever new technology comes along, so that it complements our work instead of consuming it. One of the more famous and commonly cited examples of this phenomenon is ATMs, which many predicted would make bank tellers obsolete. Yet, as Boston University’s James Bessen showed in a great , the rapid deployment of ATMs in the 1980s and 90s actually coincided with a small increase in U.S. bank teller employment over the same period: He cites two reasons for this surprising result, each of which shows how humans and markets react to new technologies in unexpected ways: First, ATMs increased the demand for tellers because they reduced the cost of operating a bank branch. Thanks to the ATM, the number of tellers required to operate a branch office in the average urban market fell from 20 to 13 between 1988 and 2004. But banks responded by opening more branches to compete for greater market share. Bank branches in urban areas increased 43 percent. Fewer tellers were required for each branch, but more branches meant that teller jobs did not disappear .Second, while ATMs automated some tasks, the remaining tasks that were not automated became more valuable. As banks pushed to increase their market shares, tellers became an important part of the “relationship banking team.” Many bank customers’ needs cannot be handled by machines—particularly small business customers’. Tellers who form a personal relationship with these customers can help sell them on high‐margin financial services and products. The skills of the teller changed: cash handling became less important and human interaction more important.In a subsequent , Bessen looked at the proliferation of computers since the 1980s and found similar effects. In fact, employment in occupations that used computers grew faster, not slower, than ones “protected” from this supposedly job‐killing technology. Even highly routine and middle‐wage occupations—jobs more likely to be destroyed—increased in these industries. It was only the lowest‐skill jobs that shrunk.