Job Guarantee increases unemployment- riskier to hire
Bourne 19 [Ryan Bourne, Chair for the Public Understanding of Economics at Cato, “Bernie Sanders Wants to End At‐Will Employment, and That’s a Truly Bad Idea That Would Increase Unemployment”, CATO Institute, December 8, 2019, https://www.cato.org/commentary/bernie-sanders-wants-end-will-employment-thats-truly-bad-idea-would-increase#:~:text=Sanders'%20goal%20is%20laudable%20but,a%20job%20if%20they%20choose.]
Despite US labor‐market flexibility delivering much lower unemployment than more heavily regulated countries, Sanders thinks it’s time to move toward more onerous employment laws. Getting rid of at‐will employment would not only make it much more difficult for inexperienced, young, and risky hires to find work, but it would also reduce wages and living standards. Democratic presidential candidates continue to demand risky and radical plans to overhaul the way Americans work. Sanders’ goal is laudable but the idea is misguided Doing away with at‐will employment means eliminating the presumption that employers should be able to fire workers at any time or for any reason, just as workers are free to walk away from a job if they choose. Federal protections against termination already exist for discrimination against protected classes. And many states have additional safeguards for workers, such as laws that prevent companies from firing workers if it would breach implied promises to the employee or is a way to punish the employee for complying with public policies. Yet Sanders’ plan goes much further. He wants a national “just cause” law, where the government would dictate what constitutes a fair layoff for personal or economic reasons, with the threat of court action and fines for employers found guilty of “unjust” dismissals. His stated desire is laudable: improving job security for workers. But security isn’t free. Making it costlier or riskier to fire people also makes it riskier to hire them. Abolishing at‐will employment entirely could make firms less likely to take on workers who are young and inexperienced, particularly when their performance is difficult to observe. The risk of such a law, then, is higher unemployment and weaker labor productivity.