Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Jobs guarantee crowds out private jobs-hurts small businesses

Bourne 19 [Ryan Bourne, Chair for the Public Understanding of Economics at Cato, “Bernie Sanders Wants to End At‐​Will Employment, and That’s a Truly Bad Idea That Would Increase Unemployment”, CATO Institute, December 8, 2019, https://www.cato.org/commentary/bernie-sanders-wants-end-will-employment-thats-truly-bad-idea-would-increase#:~:text=Sanders'%20goal%20is%20laudable%20but,a%20job%20if%20they%20choose.]

Firms could compensate for the risk burden just‐​cause laws impose by reducing the wages offered to risky hires, negating the unemployment effect. But these results suggest wages aren’t fully flexible. What’s more, Senator Sanders wants a $15 federal minimum wage and the rollout of collective bargaining nationwide, making US wages less flexible still. The combined effect of his plan to reshape the labor market would therefore be doubly damaging for the job prospects of low‐​skilled, inexperienced workers. , the impact of less labor market flexibility is clear. In part because of the flexibility of the US labor market, the unemployment rate has now fallen to an incredibly low 3.5%. By contrast, Sweden, Finland, and Denmark — which have variants of the just‐​cause laws Bernie Sanders proposes — have higher unemployment rates of 6.8%, 7.3%, and 4.8% respectively. Other European countries with much more broadly inflexible labor markets, such as France, Spain, and Italy, have much higher levels of unemployment still. The experience of the past decade suggests that although flexible labor markets can be volatile in the short term — US unemployment jumped above European levels in 2009 — they near consistently deliver lower structural unemployment over time. Sanders’ agenda doesn’t just risk unemployment, though. A just‐​cause law would likely weaken productivity and hence wages too. Silicon Valley’s success has been credited with an ability to hire and fire workers quickly according to a company’s needs. Making it difficult to hire and fire leads to workers in jobs to which they are not best suited, or else convinces employers to explore needlessly costly mechanization, reducing their efficiency. Our labor‐​market outcomes are not perfect. Many workers want more hours, more security, or higher pay. But Sanders’ idea to abolish at‐​will employment goes too far and will hurt the job prospects of inexperienced workers significantly.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.