FJG trades off with social spending
Hoffman 22 (Alex Hoffman, under the advisement of Matthew Johnson. Undergraduate Honors Thesis Sanford School of Public Policy. “Securing the Right to Work: The History and Future of Job Guarantees.” Duke University. 12/9/22.)
Many critics charge proponents of job guarantees with minimizing the true costs of their proposals. Earlier proponents of job guarantees calculated the total cost of the program simply by multiplying the total number of underemployed workers by the minimum wage (Minsky, 1986; Gordon, 1997; Wray, 1998). Both recent proposals (Paul, et al., 2018; Tcherneva, 2018) predict a budget the size of $543 billion, or 2.5% of GDP; and $514 billion to $749 billion, or 2.2% to 3.3% of GDP, respectively. Neither of these totals is precise. Both proposals underestimate the cost of their respective programs by assuming zero administrative costs including paying for the salaries of federal, state, and local officials implementing the program. At the same time, investments in the job guarantee may reduce federal spending on other social programs and increase tax revenues. The number of people requesting unemployment benefits would likely decline as the job guarantee expands and previously unemployed workers gain jobs. Similarly, increased incomes for poor 17 Americans would decrease enrollment in programs like the Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC) and Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP). Additionally, both Paul et al. and Tcherneva briefly allude to the fact that a job guarantee would increase tax revenues across the country by improving infrastructure and developing human capital through job training programs and soft skill development. Neither proposal attempts to quantify the potential cost savings of spending reductions and increased revenue, but both suggest the true cost of their programs would be lower than the price tag they provide. Regardless of the specific numbers, both proposals acknowledge that an annual budget ranging in the hundreds of billions of dollars is a nontrivial sum to fund, even through a combination of deficit spending and taxes that both plans propose.