Infrastructure won’t solve - it's an education problem
Alan et al 21 (Alan E. - Department of Homeland Security. David R. - Department of Defense. Matthew Flug - DUAL Commercial. Tino Dinh - Principal, Data Science & Analytics, Ardent Management Consulting. “IMPROVING UNITED STATES ECONOMIC COMPETITIVENESS IN THE GLOBAL MARKET.” 2021 Public-Private Analytic Exchange Program.)
Overall decline in quality in America’s public education system may lead to long term economic disadvantage for the US when competing with other countries particularly if the creation, and the protection, of new IP suffers. A decrease in the creation of IP as well as the violation thereof will likely have a deleterious effect in the realm of Green Technology, Advanced Manufacturing, and Information Technology. IP accounts for 38 percent of the US GDP and without the skills and education that lead to the creation of IP, the US will be at an increasing disadvantage globally. In short, lack of education leads to less IP creation meaning less jobs etc.; economies are built on IP. Demand for IP rights has historically tracked with global economic performance. America’s IP- intensive sectors account for nearly 45 million US jobs, is worth an estimated $6.6 trillion dollars and accounts for 38 percent of the total US GDP.96 Furthermore, IP accounts for 52 percent of all US merchandise exports amounting to roughly $842 billion and accounts for more than 40 percent of US economic growth and employment.97 In 2020, China led world in international patent applications followed by the US, Japan, the Republic of Korea, and Germany, and seeing a 16 percent increase over 2019 vice the US which saw a 3% increase over the same time period.98 According to an Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) and European Union Intellectual Property Office (EUIPO) study released in March 2019, global trade in counterfeit and pirated goods reached $509 billion in 2016, accounting for 3 percent of the global trade in goods for that year.99 According to the same study, China (combined with Hong Kong) accounted for 63 percent of the world exports of counterfeit goods in 2016 valued at $322 billion.100 Every major new industry to include automobiles, semiconductors, and biotech, among others, was launched based on IP-protected innovation. The recent implementation of mRNA technology that enabled a COVID vaccine to be produced within months of the virus’ discovery is probably one of the most poignant examples. While there has been a recent recognition that small businesses need to better understand IP and the laws that protect it, there has not been a clear approach to bridging the gap in schools; enabling creative design or understanding what IP is or how it is created is critical.101 In the US, kindergarten through 12th grade (K-12) public educational system faces a myriad of internal and external challenges to revamp school curriculums and cultures to help US public schools prepare students to enter a dynamic and globally competitive technological workforce. K-12 school staff and administration (e.g., teachers, principals, and district leaders) are currently faced with real-world decision-making in preparation for the workforce of the future on careers that have not been clearly defined (or in some cases even imagined), let alone identified and created. For example, 10 years ago space tourism was not a realistic sector, but is now a very real likelihood. With burgeoning sectors such as these, identifying the jobs that such an industry requires are both hard to imagine and more importantly begin training students at a young age to be prepared to enter. There is simply no way to know what will be required. Compounding the issue, opinions differ on how important preparing students for the future workforce really is. More than half of the 586 school and district leaders who responded to a December 2019 survey conducted by a leading, independent educational research center noted updating curriculum to get students ready for the jobs of the future is a top priority, yet 39 percent said their districts were paying at least some attention to this issue, while only 10 percent of respondents said that workforce preparation was getting only a “little” focus, and only two of the educators surveyed said their districts weren’t considering the issue at all.102 Despite the varying degree of opinion, the consensus underlying concern for school administrators appears to be that students will not be prepared for gainful employment if changes are not made to the curriculum right now. While preparing students for the future of work is a top priority, according to research conducted by an independent educational research center, there are at least five big challenges that need to be addressed regarding decision-making preparing for the future of work: 1. Differing perspectives on what public schools should focus on: College preparation vs. Workforce preparation 2. Limited Success Models and Limited Resources 3. Standardized Testing Pressure 4. Rapid Pace of Technological Change 5. Creating Meaningful Internships
Many alt causes to economic competitiveness
Alan et al 21 (Alan E. - Department of Homeland Security. David R. - Department of Defense. Matthew Flug - DUAL Commercial. Tino Dinh - Principal, Data Science & Analytics, Ardent Management Consulting. “IMPROVING UNITED STATES ECONOMIC COMPETITIVENESS IN THE GLOBAL MARKET.” 2021 Public-Private Analytic Exchange Program.)
For the US to facilitate driving domestic and global economic growth, the US should create a framework of incentives to improve economic competitiveness by: 41 1. Establishing a NIS framework and leadership mechanism for (i) understanding long-term issues that affect the US ability to maintain its competitive advantage in the present and future, including the countering of malign foreign influence, and (ii) implementing a long-term economic strategy that accounts for the rapid and long-term rise of China’s economy 2. Enhancing Public-Private Partnerships between the USG and private sector through executive- or legislative-directed programs that promote collaboration and incentivizes. 3. Protecting US access to critical resources, dual-use technologies, IP, capital investment, and trade relationships 4. Ensuring the US education system is adequately preparing the next generation of the workforce for future needs and challenges which face the nation 5. Bolstering foreign direct investment and free trade while concurrently applying investment security protocols that do not upset the flow of information and goods, and ensuring the nation has access to critical resources and technology 6. Creating a program that would match private investments with public investment dollars and resources into critical companies, technologies, or industries determined to serve economic or national security requirements. This cost-share model would incentivize the private sector and reduce investment risk while leveraging capital to the USG’s benefit For the US to maintain economic and national security, the USG must continue to foster deep and meaningful relationships with the private sector and foreign allied governments. These relationships will cultivate a next generation view of the world order and ensure policies and procedures continue to facilitate legitimate trade and the flow of goods, ideas, people, and capital, while balancing the importance of national security goals. A unified, whole of government approach that is responsive to changes in the global marketplace will support a cost- effective international trade system and fuel prospering economies. Alignment between government and private sector priorities – guided by incentivizes for participation – will accelerate the cohesion between countries and people, giving new growth to economies.