Decline is peaceful and necessary to avoid war
MacDonald 2018 - Associate Professor of Political Science @ Wellesley College Paul K and Joseph M. Parent, Twilight of the Titans: Great Power Decline and Retrenchment, Cornell U Press, p. 179-180
Pessimism is a staple in political discourse, but seldom has there been so much of it surrounding America’s role in the world. We have argued that the prevailing wisdom about the dangers of decline is misleading. Relative decline is common; war and death spirals are not. These facts alone should discourage panic or overreaction. Even beyond war, decline has the opposite effect to that which scholars have posited over an array of measures. Instead of pushing states to belligerence in disputes short of war, decline is one of the most powerful forces pulling states to peace. The case studies have shown that there is a great deal of ruin in nations, but serious reforms have regularly surmounted setbacks and dysfunction. In fact, recovery is a real possibility. States have healthy competitive instincts and decline opens space for institutional overhauls. Rather than being puppets of structural forces, declining powers have room to shape their policies in ways that make them more viable, but less violent. In short, there are good grounds for optimism in decline. Declining powers are not inclined to unleash violence, nor are they tied up by competing bureaucracies, interest groups, or parties. The most frequent response to decline is not belligerence but retrenchment. Great powers align their ends and means to better defend core interests, refi t and refuel institutions, and reallocate resources for more productive investment. Retrenchment does not always lead to recovery, but under a wide variety of conditions it is preferable to the alternatives: expanding out, lashing out, or holding on. If this argument is correct, then the deep and abiding pessimism about the capacity of the United States to manage the rise of new great power rivals is misplaced. Pundits have it backwards: if power politics is returning, those forces are more likely to preserve peace than preclude it.