FJG would be detrimental – cost, administrative challenges, and economic vulnerability
Gulker 18 (Max Gulker - Senior Research Fellow at the American Institute for Economic Research. Gulker holds a PhD in economics from Stanford University and a BA in economics from the University of Michigan. “Executive Summary: The Jobs Guarantee: A Critical Analysis.” American Institute for Economic Research. https://www.aier.org/article/the-job-guarantee-a-critical-analysis-executive-summary/)
The primary goal of this report is to show why a federal job guarantee is a clear-cut case in which the proposed cure is worse than the disease. The proposals described by the CBPP and Levy reports would constitute nothing less than the single largest government intervention in US economic history. According to the reports’ own estimates, a federal job guarantee would incur a higher cost in one to two years than the entire New Deal in today’s dollars. A federal job guarantee would be monumentally expensive, return only limited value from the participants’ work, entail administrative challenges nearly impossible to solve, and be potentially disastrous for economic growth and the private labor market. Relying on rigorous but basic economics and data analysis, we find the following: Job-guarantee participants would be placed in a system that eschewed the most fundamental ways that markets provide information and incentives, such as competition and freely set wages (section 3). Under the authors’ own projections of ten to seventeen million participants, a federal job guarantee would, by several-fold, create the world’s largest organization (public or private) measured by employees (section 4). Under the authors’ own projections, the program’s annual cost would be comparable to that of the Pentagon (section 4). There are multiple reasons why the CBPP and Levy reports may have underestimated participation and cost (section 4). Both the CBPP and Levy reports set standards for the type of work to be provided that would be difficult if not impossible to attain, place burdens on state and local governments, and return work of very limited value (section 5). An on-demand job guarantee of the scale and scope proposed could cause massive distortions in the wider economy leading to less output and growth, and could prevent workers from investing in critical human capital (section 6). While many commentators have expressed grave concern with job-guarantee proposals, this article represents one of the first detailed analyses of the claims advanced by the policy’s proponents. Because of the unprecedented size and scope of the CBPP and Levy programs, some have dismissed the seriousness of a federal job guarantee as a policy proposal. On the left, economist Paul Krugman has said that “realistically, a blanket jobs guarantee is unlikely to happen.”