Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The jobs guarantee fails- the real issue is quality of jobs, not quantity

Kim 18

Anne Kim, senior at progressive policy institute, Guarantees Jobs To gib to Succeed, ppi

A second and more serious conceptual flaw with a jobs guarantee is that it seeks to solve the wrong problem. While the lack of jobs is a continuing concern for some groups in some areas and absolutely should not be overlooked, the biggest malady ailing the middle and working classes isn’t so much the quantity of jobs as their quality – in the form of stagnant wages, declining benefits and the loss of stability and security. In this context, a national jobs guarantee program isn’t just too big a hammer, but the wrong tool altogether. Though wages are finally ticking upward, the long-term trend toward stagnation is still far from being erased. The Brookings Institution, for example, reports that real wages for the middle quintile of workers grew by only between 1979 and 2016, while labor’s share of national income has also steadily fallen despite healthy corporate profits. More Americans are also losing access to traditional employer-provided benefits, such as health insurance. At the same time that the share of employers offering health insurance has dropped by 10 percentage points since 1999, according to the , more Americans are finding themselves to be no longer employees at all but members of the ever-precarious “gig economy.” Especially vulnerable are the workers with the least amount of education, the one group that has remained consistently underemployed despite rising fortunes for others. In March, for instance, just of Americans without a high school diploma were working, compared to 72.6 percent for college graduates. While a jobs guarantee program could potentially help some of these less-educated workers, a big question is why they should be shunted to relatively low-skilled public jobs rather than given the opportunity to increase their skills and compete for skilled openings.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.