Policymakers have an ethical obligation to frame climate policy to reduce inequality and focus on structural injustice
Saurabh Biswas et al in 2022
Angel Echevarria, Nafeesa Irshad, Yiamar Rivera-Matos, Jennifer Richter, Nalini Chhetri, Mary Jane Parmentier & Clark A. Miller; Authors and Affiliations Pacific Northwest National Laboratory, Saurabh Biswas; School for the Future of Innovation in Society, Arizona State University, Angel Echevarria, Nafeesa Irshad, Yiamar Rivera-Matos, Jennifer Richter, Nalini Chhetri, Mary Jane Parmentier & Clark A. Miller; Ending the Energy-Poverty Nexus: An Ethical Imperative for Just Transitions; Science and Engineering Ethics volume 28, Article number: 36 (2022)
Arguments for a just transition are integral to debates about climate change and the drive to create a carbon-neutral future. Decarbonizing the energy sector involves disruptive changes to both energy technologies and broader societies and economies (Miller et al., 2013, 2015). In the past, energy transitions have wrought major shifts in industries, regulations, workforces, and markets (Jones, 2014), as well as the forms and geographies of resource extraction (Pasqualetti, 2011). As a result, profound ethical questions arise about the meaning and impact of energy transitions for diverse groups of people within and across societies (Jasanoff, 2011, 2018; Miller, 2014; Sovacool et al., 2017). Proponents of a just transition insist, therefore, that the design and navigation of future energy transitions acknowledge and mitigate the resulting disruptions in people’s lives, livelihoods, health, and environments. As the Just Transition Alliance (2020) put it, for example: “Just Transition” is a principle, a process and a practice. The principle of just transition is that a healthy economy and a clean environment can and should co-exist. The process for achieving this vision should be a fair one that should not cost workers or community residents their health, environment, jobs, or economic assets. Any losses should be fairly compensated. And the practice of just transition means that the people who are most affected by pollution—the frontline workers and the fenceline communities—should be in the leadership of crafting policy solutions. This definition encompasses both an ethical and a justice-oriented stance. Energy ethics and justice are overlapping fields. Both raise questions about the normative dimensions of energy transitions. Energy ethics is concerned with the social principles, values, and norms that govern energy transitions. Energy justice uses distributive, recognition, and procedural frameworks familiar from environmental justice movements to interrogate and challenge patterns of inequitable distributions of benefits and burdens in an energy transition, focusing especially on historically marginalized populations and communities (Bethem et al., 2020; Bickerstaff, 2017; Biswas et al., 2021; Heffron & McCauley, 2017; Jenkins et al., 2018; McCauley et al., 2019; Jetten et al., 2020; Sovacool & Dworkin, 2015). Questions of distributive justice interrogate how the benefits and burdens of energy systems and transitions are distributed across groups. Recognition justice “refers to the acknowledgement of, and respect for, the complex circumstances and vulnerabilities of individuals and social groups in patterns of cultural value” (Lewis et al., 2020, p 425–426). Procedural and participatory justice focus on how decisions get made, the differential abilities of and opportunities for groups to contribute to and shape decision-making, and the institutional barriers that limit or constrain their participation. Two broad approaches rooted in ethics and justice currently frame discussions of just energy transitions, and are present in the Just Transition Alliance quote above. The first can be described as internal to the transition and emphasizes the anticipation, assessment, and redressing of harms created by the transition itself and the inclusion in transition governance of groups or communities potentially harmed by its disruptions. This approach tends to focus on current coal, oil, or gas workers whose employment is threatened (Pai et al., 2020; Pai & Carr-Wilson, 2018, 2019); communities that may lose tax revenues or businesses due to the decline of these industries or confront environmental risks from legacy infrastructures stranded by the transition (Roemer & Haggerty, 2021); or communities confronting challenges due to the siting of new energy infrastructures, such as lithium mines, solar and wind farms, or natural gas wells (Barandiaran, 2015; Kinchy, 2017; Mulvaney, 2019). In this paper, we focus on a second approach to ethics and justice in energy transitions, which is systemic or societal in scope. This approach complements attention to the proximate dynamics and impacts of the transition itself with a focus on the distant societal and economic outcomes the transition brings into being and how they compare to conditions prior to the transition. It poses the question: do the transformative social, economic, and technological changes wrought by energy transitions create more just societies and economies, or do they instead reinforce or recreate long-standing injustices and inequalities? The present reality is that carbon-based energy systems systematically help create and foster a wide range of structural inequalities and injustices across markets and societies (Sovacool, 2016). We propose, therefore, that those leading energy transitions have an ethical obligation to redress these existing inequalities and injustices, in addition to proactively addressing any potential additional harms created by the transition process, thus contributing to more just, equitable, and fair societies and markets. This can be accomplished by using ethical and justice principles and practices to inform the (re)design of energy systems and the work of carrying out energy transitions by institutions in the energy sector and with regulatory or governance authority over energy, as well as by civil society organizations and communities working with them. Ultimately, we argue, just transitions to carbon-neutral energy systems should promote the creation of alternative socio-energy arrangements that intentionally create and improve positive social, political, economic and environmental conditions and outcomes for the world’s lowest income and least well-off communities, rather than continue to diminish them.