The Green new deal is key to creating systemic economic changes that address inequity and transition the US to renewable energy- now is key
Boyle et al in 21
Alaina D. Boyle, Graham Leggat, Larissa Morikawa, Yanni Pappas, Jennie C. Stephens; Green New Deal proposals: Comparing emerging transformational climate policies at multiple scales; Energy Research & Social Science Volume 81, November 2021, 102259;
As wildfires, hurricanes, droughts, floods, extreme temperatures, and other climate disruptions worsen around the world, it is increasingly recognized that systemic change facilitated by transformational policy is required to prevent the human and economic losses currently projected [1], [2]. Widespread recognition of the deep interconnections among climate change, social equity, and economic activity has led to a growing transformation-focused climate justice movement that advocates for equity and social justice to be at the core of all climate policy [1], [2], [3], [4], [5], [6], [7]. Moving away from proposed climate policies that exacerbate and perpetuate economic disparities, a new set of policies are rapidly emerging that focus on a just transition, where communities that will be most affected by the shift away from fossil fuels to a renewable-based low-carbon society are empowered and supported. These policies explicitly address the social and economic structures that have enabled the worsening climate crisis, and prioritize protecting vulnerable populations both locally and internationally [8]. Among the most prominent and influential of these new proposed policies is the US Green New Deal (GND) Resolution (H.R. 109 Recognizing the duty of the Federal Government to create a Green New Deal), which was proposed in 2018 and introduced in the U.S. Congress in February 2019 [9]. In 14 pages, the 2019 GND resolution describes large-scale national goals across sectors for greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions and pollution reductions, employment, infrastructure, housing, health and equity. The breadth and ambition of the proposal, which calls for 10 years of intensive investment and mobilization, is justified with references to recent climate science reports that call for urgent action. The resolution is based on the assertion that climate change is a direct threat to the United States, exacerbating environmental, economic, and social instabilities, and that the Federal Government, therefore, has both a responsibility and an opportunity to make large public investments to accelerate the transition to a green, healthy economy through job training, job creation, infrastructure, healthcare, and housing. By explicitly invoking the New Deal from the 1940s, the GND recalls the example of large-scale U.S. Federal investment in public mobilization to alleviate unemployment, develop physical infrastructure, and enact public works [10]. Despite the widely perceived success of the New Deal in stimulating positive outcomes for American society, the proposed GND (H.R. 109) has been met with vigorous opposition, and the economic and political feasibility of the proposed policy vision has been hotly debated [11]. Public opinion of the GND, which was developed and proposed by liberal Democrats, has polarized primarily along party lines as the Republican Party has opposed both large public investments and climate action, although there has also been some pushback by centrist Democrats. Given the partisan associations of the major media outlets in the US, soon after the GND was first proposed, many Republicans harshly critiqued it in part due to what Gustafson et al. (2019) call the “Fox News effect”, where more critical coverage by the outlet caused a sharp decline in support for the policy among conservative Republicans [8]. Despite the rigorous, partisan political debates about the federal GND resolution, other new proposals asserting the need for integrated multi-sectoral coordination and investment at other levels of government, including state, municipal, regional, and tribal, have been rapidly emerging. While ambitious climate policies that address justice have been implemented in other countries, H.R. 109 was the first to explicitly connect unprecedented investment in social, economic, and climate goals to a just transition for local communities and more equitable climate outcomes relative to GHG emissions globally [12]. Building on the ambition and inspiration of the US national-level proposal, these GND-type policies have been proposed to spur major public investment in multiple interconnected aspects of the transition toward a renewable-based society including the environment, labor, and infrastructure across multiple levels of government, from US cities to the EU. A broad range of communities, advocates, and organizations have leveraged the GND framework to advocate for their priorities including Indigenous rights, racial equity, and labor rights. Although some proposals using the GND framework include specific economic and policy mechanisms, the initial federal GND proposal of 2019 focuses on broad goals and leaves the specifics of policy design and implementation to be developed. Emerging research on the feasibility of the national GND is growing, including studies integrating economic, political, and systemic transition framework lenses [3], [13], [14], [15], [16]. Most of this work was published prior to the start of the COVID-19 pandemic, before the unprecedented federal investment in the US workforce through the CARES (Coronavirus Aid, Relief and Economic Security) Act that followed, and before the need for massive public investments in the United States was so much more acute and widespread. In a time where cities and regions across the world face immense increases in unemployment rates and the depths of social inequalities revealed and exacerbated by COVID-19, pandemic recovery offers a new mechanism to provide public investments to simultaneously achieve multiple goals including creating jobs, addressing a legacy of injustices, and accelerating a transition toward renewable energy. In both the United States and Europe, the GND framework has been explicitly recognized as a crucial framework for confronting the climate crisis as part of pandemic recovery. Not all climate policies that apply a GND-type framework, however, use the language of the GND to connect explicitly to the original GND proposal. The Biden administration, for example, appears to be taking a “quiet” approach to climate policy; avoiding linking their climate policies to the GND in an attempt to avoid the kind of polarizing media coverage and political opposition that has hindered H.R. 109 since its introduction [8], [17]. In contrast to the Biden/Harris administration being careful not to explicitly associate its ambitious climate plans as embracing the proposed GND, the European Commission integrates the 2019 European Green Deal with COVID-19 recovery in NextGenerationEU [18].