Focusing on technological innovation undermines environmental protection and exacerbates inequality by foreclosing systemic change
Jennie C. Stephens in 2022
School of Public Policy and Urban Affairs, Northeastern University; Beyond Climate Isolationism: a Necessary Shift for Climate Justice; Current Climate Change Reports volume 8, pages83–90 (2022);
By focusing almost exclusively on technological innovation, climate isolationism obfuscates the potential for transformative social change and diminishes the priority of investing in climate resilient innovations that simultaneously advance social justice [31]. Climate isolationism limits public discourse and constrains the voices of diverse constituents,this is a part of larger trend of people and communities being disempowered to be involved in policy decision-making [54, 56], especially when they are perceived as scientific issues [42]. The persistence of the narrow climate isolationism perspective has been beneficial for the polluter elite, those wealthy individuals, and organizations that do not want transformative change because they are profiting from fossil fuel reliance and exploitative corporate business practices [38]. Climate denialism, which has been supported by fossil fuel interests and the polluter elite, has also required climate decision-makers to spend a lot of time and energy defending what is known about the science of climate change [51]. The polluter elite’s decades-long strategic misinformation campaign to confuse the public about the science of climate change has been an effective delay tactic [22]. The prevalence of climate denialism has confined climate discourse to the scientific realm and limited options for non-scientific discourse about how to respond to the climate crisis and reduce climate vulnerabilities. Continuing to increase investment in technological innovation while underinvesting in social innovation is preventing the transformative changes that are required both for stabilizing the climate and for reducing social injustice. So, not only does climate isolationism result in missed opportunities to advance social and economic justice, but it also results in insufficient environmental protection [31]. One example of the dangerous implications of climate isolationism and how it contributes to concentrating wealth and power is the recent increased interest in investing in solar geoengineering research [71]. The National Academies recently released a report providing recommendations for advancing research on solar geoengineering, which is a technological intervention in the climate system that involves spraying aerosols into the atmosphere to block incoming solar radiation [49]. Once on the fringes of climate policy, solar geoengineering is gaining traction, particularly in the USA, where some are calling for substantial public investments in solar geoengineering research [49]. The ultimate “technical fix” [46, 67, 77], this approach does nothing to address the cause of climate change, and the social and political risks of advancing this cannot be understated [68].