Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Framing in terms of systemic change is key- technocratic solutions lead to incremental reforms that fail to address social inequality

Jennie C. Stephens in 2022

School of Public Policy and Urban Affairs, Northeastern University; Beyond Climate Isolationism: a Necessary Shift for Climate Justice; Current Climate Change Reports volume 8, pages83–90 (2022);

As the climate crisis worsens and continues to reveal stark injustices and inhumane inequities in society, the evidence suggests that our decision-making and policy processes have resulted in ineffective and inadequate responses in both climate mitigation [73] and climate adaptation [39]. The systemic, transformative changes that are needed to end fossil fuel reliance and to invest in supporting the most vulnerable people and communities have not yet been prioritized. A key contributor to the insufficient actions taken so far toward a more just and sustainable future is the fact that climate decision-making has been all-too-often constrained within a narrow technocratic lens which I call “climate isolationism” [63, 64]. I have coined this term to characterize the common framing of climate change as an isolated, discrete, scientific problem in need of technological solutions. Decision-makers working within a lens of climate isolationism often focus in a quantitative way on carbon reductions, greenhouse gas emissions, and temperature changes while inadvertently ignoring the societal complexities and social injustices associated with these quantitative measures [30]. This narrow technocratic lens is prevalent in decision-making around both climate mitigation and climate adaptation. When climate isolationism is applied to climate mitigation, decarbonization is usually the goal [26], carbon accounting is the primary metric, and incentives and costs of a variety of different mitigating technologies are often projected and compared [5]. When climate isolationism is applied to climate adaptation, a disproportionate focus on investing in technical infrastructure (i.e., sea walls and drought-resistant crops) often detracts attention and investment from social innovation and social changes that could enhance climate resilience [59]. This paper reviews the inadequacy and dangers of climate isolationism, explores why climate justice provides an alternative more effective framing, and calls for more intentional consideration of power and power dynamics in climate decision-making to shift from climate isolationism to climate justice. This review is based on a US-based perspective with potential for global application.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.