The round should be evaluated through a lens of climate justice- only a recognition of the relationship between socio-economic inequality and climate can ensure the holistic approach key to solve
Jennie C. Stephens in 2022
School of Public Policy and Urban Affairs, Northeastern University; Beyond Climate Isolationism: a Necessary Shift for Climate Justice; Current Climate Change Reports volume 8, pages83–90 (2022);
Moving beyond the lens of climate isolationism, climate justice provides a more productive, complex, and holistic framework within which to assess and prioritize responses to the climate crisis [58, 70]. Climate justice requires recognizing that: (1) many policies, processes, and practices of wealthy elite institutions and individuals are the drivers of climate change, (2) the impacts of climate disruptions and the capacity to adapt are distributed unequally among and within local and global communities; and (3) equitable climate adaptation and strengthening climate resilience requires new transformative investments, innovations, and actions to rectify the disproportionate burdens on those who are most vulnerable to ongoing and future climate impacts [27]. Decision-making within a climate justice frame involves striving for transformative systemic changes that integrate technological and social innovation while prioritizing equity and social, racial, and economic justice. Just as Ibram X Kendi explains in his book “How to be an Antiracist” (2019) that there is no such thing as neutrality when it comes to considering systemic racism [37], there is no policy that is neutral on climate justice. Policies and decisions at every level are either perpetuating climate injustices if they are not intentionally and explicitly trying to reduce climate injustices. Given the racial and economic injustices associated with fossil fuel reliance [28] and fossil fuel combustion [47], a societal transformation toward a renewable-based society needs to be prioritized. The case for keeping fossil fuels in the ground can be made from a climate isolationism lens, however, the case becomes so much more compelling and practical when the social justice opportunities are also explicitly called out [41]. To move beyond climate isolationism toward climate justice, climate decision-making has to focus more explicitly on power dynamics and social innovations to redistribute power to people and communities who are most vulnerable. Climate decision-making needs to explicitly consider how policies, practices, and priorities either reinforce or disrupt the systems that are currently concentrating wealth and power. For less powerful groups to gain a foothold in decision-making processes, renewed attention to the multiple ways that social, economic, and political power shape social change must be acknowledged [34]. Feminist theory offers expertise in the study of power [11], so embracing a feminist lens is one valuable approach to moving away from climate isolationism toward climate justice. The social science literature on sociotechnical transitions has been critiqued for minimizing the role of power [6], and a recent contribution by Avelino [7] identifies seven specific ways to consider power in decision-making, processes of change, and innovation: (1) power over versus power to, (2) centered versus diffused, (3) consensual versus conflictual, (4) constraining versus enabling, (5) quantity versus quality, (6) empowerment versus disempowerment, and (7) power in relation to knowledge [7]. As jurisdictions around the world grapple with the interconnected crises of housing and food insecurity, climate disruptions, and economic precarity, narrow efforts to reduce greenhouse gas emissions or control the global average temperature are likely to cause more harm than good. New ways of strategically integrating climate action into other social policies, in the way that the Biden/Harris administration integrated their climate agenda into pandemic recovery and inflation reduction investments, provides an empirical example of the practical valuable potential of moving away from climate isolationism [52].