Green new deal is key to systemic change- it recognizes the futility of small technocratic fixes and uses an integrative approach that shows the connection between socioeconomic structures and climate change
Boyle et al in 21
Alaina D. Boyle, Graham Leggat, Larissa Morikawa, Yanni Pappas, Jennie C. Stephens; Green New Deal proposals: Comparing emerging transformational climate policies at multiple scales; Energy Research & Social Science Volume 81, November 2021, 102259;
Policy proposals applying a GND framework are part of a new approach to climate policy that is distinct from both previously proposed traditional cost-based climate policies and business as usual (BAU), which assumes continued reliance on fossil fuels (Fig. 1). Throughout this paper we refer to GND proposals or GND-like policies as a new type of integrated climate policy that applies the GND framework including some policy proposals that do not explicitly use the words Green New Deal. Traditional cost-based climate policies, including carbon taxes and cap-and-trade policies, have dominated public policy discourse around climate change. Traditional policies focus on market-based approaches and are based on the economic assumption that climate change is an externality that can be addressed by internalizing costs [19]. These policies, which result from a “climate isolationist” technocratic framing of climate change as a discrete and isolated problem in need of a technological solution, tend to focus narrowly on greenhouse gas emissions reductions [20]. Although market-based policies have contributed to some renewable energy gains and reductions in GHG emissions, market-based policies alone increasingly appear to be insufficient to achieve the systemic transformation needed to both drastically reduce GHG emissions and build the resilience needed to minimize climate-based catastrophes and the resulting human and economic losses [1], [3], [21], [22], [23], [24]. The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) developed Representative Concentration Pathways (RCPs) projecting climate change in response to different climate policy approaches [25]. In these pathways, BAU represents the future without additional climate policy; a continuation of a predominately fossil-fuel based energy system. This system perpetuates structural inequity of climate impacts and resource access, leading to climate displacement and increased morbidity and mortality for the most vulnerable [2], [26]. Without any ambitious new climate policies, either GND-like policies or cost-based climate policies, a future still dominated by fossil fuel use, continued economic precarity and inequities, and devastating climate disruptions can be expected (Fig. 1). Although the IPCC’s RCPs project the future through 2100, the figure reflects that GND policies propose nearer-term targets through 2050. The GND framework differs from other types of climate policies because it is based on large-scale investments designed to increase community resilience to climate disruptions as well as reduce emissions. The goals of GND proposals are not just based on short-term, cost-effective shifts to decarbonize the economy; they also include long-term social and economic outcomes related to jobs, health, and social equity. While most prior proposed climate policies assume emissions reductions targets will be met by incentivizing technological development or economic mechanisms including carbon taxes, GND proposals contextualize emissions reductions as a benefit within an economic re-orientation away from fossil fuels, linking investments in renewable infrastructure and employment while addressing social inequities [27]. GND proponents argue that the environmental damage of fossil fuel reliance and social inequities are inextricably linked, so policies addressing these problems will not be effective unless they are simultaneously addressing both [28]. The GND framework can be characterized as a component of a just transition that incorporates consideration for the employment effects of the economic shift to renewable energy and the longstanding harms to frontline communities from fossil fuel energy pollution [4]. To address this complex set of issues, GND proposals typically feature multiple sections to contextualize and describe environmental, economic, and social goals, including clean energy, equity, health, and emissions reductions. As a multi-sectoral economy-wide approach to climate, GND policies include investments in climate mitigation, adaptation, and resilience. This integrated approach offers an opportunity for broader transformational social change and offers opportunities for addressing climate justice and economic justice with decarbonization [20]. Given the scale of the climate challenges ahead, GND policies recognize that the scale of climate action needed is beyond incremental adjustments that recombine the existing elements of socio-economic structures [1], [29]. These policies acknowledge that systemic transformation requires social innovation to create economic decoupling from carbon consumption, where increased economic activity does not directly contribute to increased carbon consumption [29]. While some scholars and activists suggest degrowth – which focuses on reducing economic activity to meet physical ecological boundaries – is critical for the societal transformation that is needed, the decoupling included in GND proposals assumes continued resource consumption but in ways that do not contribute to GHG emissions. Some scholars argue that a GND featuring decoupling, rather than degrowth, is necessary to meet rising standards of living and expand job opportunities not only in the Global North, but worldwide [27].