Shifting the government’s attention to economy is key- China’s growing economically and challenges Western hegemonic superiority
Jaeger 22, Markus Jaeger, Dr. Markus Jaeger is a research fellow at DGAP and an adjunct professor at Columbia University. Prior to joining DGAP, Jaeger was a director at Deutsche Bank Research in New York, where he was responsible for the analysis of US economic and financial markets. Previously, he held a variety of research and advisory roles with Deutsche Bank in London and New York, covering global economics and emerging markets as well as country risk and geopolitics.“The Economics of Great Power Competition,” DCAP, May 02, 2022, https://dgap.org/en/research/publications/economics-great-power-competition//Isim
The United States and its allies are status quo powers; China and Russia are revisionist powers. Russia wants to change the status quo in Eastern Europe, China in East Asia. Despite the Ukraine war, China continues to present a greater long-term challenge to the status quo than Russia. China is rising economically, while Russia is experiencing stagnation and relative decline. Whether Russo-Chinese cooperation intensifies or not, China’s rise has important implications for American strategy, transatlantic relations, and German and European defense policy. The United States is strongly committed to defending the status quo in Asia as well as in Europe, and it has good reasons for doing so. Preventing the rise of a hegemonic power on either side of the Eurasian landmass has been a strategic interest for more than a century. The United States fought two world wars and committed to an extensive forward military presence and extensive security guarantees during the Cold War to prevent Europe and East Asia from falling under German, Japanese, or Soviet hegemony. Whether or not a Sino-Russian geopolitical bloc emerges, both China and Russia are set on a collision course with the United States and its allies. Economically, the US-led alliances are well-positioned to engage in long-term geopolitical competition, provided the United States manages to maintain alliance cohesion. But to remain competitive, America will need to shift attention and resources to Asia – Russian revisionist policies notwithstanding. This will force its European allies to take on greater responsibility for defending the status quo in Europe. Germany has a pivotal role to play here. As the economically and financially most powerful country in Europe, it will have little choice but to contribute to strengthening European security. Unlike smaller countries, it cannot free-ride on the security provided by its European allies. Germany also has at its disposal greater economic, financial, and technological resources than its European partners. The main challenge will be to convert economic resources into military power and enhanced security in an efficient and effective way. Economic might is the foundation of political and military power. It is also a prerequisite for engaging in successful long-term geopolitical competition. Paul Kennedy and Robert Gilpin have famously argued that shifting economic fortunes underpin the rise and fall of great powers. The economically stronger or ascendant power, or alliance of powers, emerges victorious, often but not always in the wake of a ‘hegemonic war.’ Anecdotal evidence suggests that more forceful military mobilization or more innovative military tactics may confer a temporary advantage, but rarely translate into strategic victory. How do the US-led alliances on the one hand and China and Russia on the other hand compare in terms of economic power? At present, the aggregate economic resources of the United States and its allies outstrip the combined resources of China and Russia. But the current and prospective ‘balance of economic resources’ is much more favorable for the status quo powers in Europe than in Asia. The economies of European NATO members are five times larger than Russia’s, and even prior to the imposition of the war-related sanctions, the Russian economy was already stagnating. Its long-term growth outlook is weak, given its demographics, dependence on natural resource exports, and uncompetitive domestic markets. Russia will be lucky if its growth rate matches that of low-growth major European economies like France and Germany, especially if the substantial one-off drop due to sanctions is taken into account. In Asia, however, the aggregate economic size of the US-led alliances exceeds China’s by a far smaller margin. The Chinese economy is also growing much faster. Under reasonable assumptions, it will be twice as large as the US economy by the middle of this century. It will then exceed the combined economic size of the United States and its regional allies. These are baseline projections, and it is worth noting that significant risks attach to China’s future growth trajectory, much more than to the outlook of the mature, lower-growth advanced economies of the United States and allies. Chinese growth has averaged nearly ten percent a year since its economic opening in the late 1970s. More recently, trend growth has dropped closer to six percent and is set to decline further. China’s official 2022 target is five and a half percent. By comparison, the present US growth potential is estimated to be around two percent or less. China certainly has sufficient savings to finance capital accumulation. But this is of little use if not enough profitable investment opportunities can be identified. Doubling down on infrastructure investment will only lead to excess debt accumulation and raises the risk of a financial and economic crisis. Rapidly deteriorating demographics, a declining catch-up growth potential, and the so-called middle-income trap represent considerable risks to China’s economic outlook. So-called economic rebalancing to make growth more sustainable is proving challenging. Nevertheless, in all reasonable scenarios, Chinese economic growth will exceed American growth. The Chinese economy will therefore continue to pull ahead of the American economy. This will allow China to increase defense expenditure far more rapidly than the United States and its allies, while keeping it stable as a share of GDP and thereby limiting the resource drain on the economy. China’s increasing economic might will force the United States to mobilize and allocate greater resources to Asia. With Chinese capabilities focused on Asia, the United States – which deploys its military assets globally – will face an increasingly difficult strategic challenge. As a result, America’s European allies will need to take greater responsibility for European defense.