Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The aff’s explicit formulation of environmental problems as structurally related to socio-politics is key- it forecloses piecemeal incrementalism in favor of radical change

Erik Swyngedouw in 6 Department of Geography, School of Environment and Development, Manchester University, Impossible “Sustainability” and the Post-Political Condition, Forthcoming in: David Gibbs and Rob Krueger (Eds.) Sustainable Development Guilford Press, New York.

Therefore, as Badiou (2005a) argues, a new radical politics must revolve around the construction of great new fictions that create real possibilities for constructing different socio-environmental futures. To the extent that the current post-political condition, which combines apocalyptic environmental visions with a hegemonic neoliberal view of social ordering, constitutes one particular fiction (one that in fact forecloses dissent, conflict, and the possibility of a different future), there is an urgent need for different stories and fictions that can be mobilised for realisation. This requires foregrounding and naming different socio-environmental futures, making the new and impossible enter the realm of politics and of democracy, and recognizing conflict, difference, and struggle over the naming and trajectories of these futures. Socio-environmental conflict, therefore, should not be subsumed under the homogenizing mantle of a populist environmentalist-sustainability discourse, but should be legitimised as constitutive of a democratic order. In the final paragraphs of this chapter, I shall outline what constitutes for me, the key drivers of conflict and where the possibilities for different fictions, and consequently new environmental futures, might tentatively reside. Processes of socio-physical entanglement (what Marx called metabolic circulation) transform both social and physical environments and produce specific, differentiated and unique social and physical milieus with new and distinct qualities (Swyngedouw, 2006). In other words, environments are combined socio-physical constructions that are actively (both by humans and non-humans) and historically produced, both in terms of social content and physical-environmental qualities. Whether we consider the making urban parks, natural reserves, or skyscrapers, they each contain and express fused socio-physical processes that contain and embody particular metabolic and social relations (see Heynen, Kaika, and Swyngedouw, 2006). There is, in this sense, no single Nature, no One-All, but rather a great variety of distinct and often radically different (if not antagonistic) natures. There is nothing a-priory unnatural or unsustainable, therefore, about produced environments like cities, genetically modified organisms, dammed rivers, or irrigated fields. The world is a Cyborg world, part natural part social, part technical part cultural, but with no clear boundaries, centres, or margins. The type and character of physical and environmental change, and the resulting socio-environmental flows, networks and practices are not independent from the specific historical social, cultural, political, or economic conditions and the institutions that accompany them. All socio-spatial processes are invariably also predicated upon the circulation and metabolism of physical, chemical, or biological components. Non-humans of course play an active role in mobilizing socio-natural circulatory and metabolic processes. It is these circulatory conduits that link often distant places and ecosystems together and permit relating local processes with wider socio-metabolic flows, networks, configurations, and dynamics. These socio-environmental metabolisms produce a series of both enabling and disabling socio-environmental conditions. Of course, such produced milieus often embody contradictory or conflicting tendencies. While environmental (both social and physical) qualities may be enhanced in some places and for some humans and non-humans, they often lead to a deterioration of social, physical, and/or ecological conditions and qualities elsewhere. Processes of metabolic change are, therefore, never socially or ecologically neutral. This results in conditions under which particular trajectories of socio-environmental change undermine the stability or coherence of some social groups, places or ecologies, while their sustainability elsewhere might be enhanced. Social power relations (whether material or discursive, economic, political, and/or cultural) through which metabolic circulatory processes take place are particularly important. It is these power geometries, the human and non-human actors, and the socio-natural networks carrying them that ultimately decide who will have access to or control over, and who will be excluded from access to or control over, resources or other components of the environment and who or what will be positively or negatively enrolled in such metabolic imbroglios. These power geometries, in turn, shape the particular social and political configurations and the environments in which we live. Henri Lefebvre’s ‘Right to the City’ also invariably implies a ‘Right to Metabolism’. Questions of socio-environmental sustainability are fundamentally political questions revolving around attempts to tease out who (or what) gains from and who pays for, who benefits from and who suffers (and in what ways) from particular processes of metabolic circulatory change. Such politicisation seeks answers to questions about what or who needs to be sustained and how this can be maintained or achieved. This includes naming socio-environmental trajectories, enrolling them in a political process that is radically differentiated and oppositional. Clearly, Bush’s notion of and desire for sustainability is not that of a Chinese peasant, a maquiladora woman worker or a Greenpeace activist. It is important to unravel the nature of the social relationships that unfold between individuals and social groups and how these, in turn, are mediated by and structured through processes of socio-ecological change. In other words, environmental transformation is not independent from class, gender, ethnic, or other power struggles. Socio-ecological ‘sustainability’ can only be achieved by means of a democratically (in the sense of a genuine political space) organised process of socio-environmental (re)-construction. The political program is to enhance the democratic content of socio-environmental construction by means of identifying the strategies through which a more equitable distribution of social power and a democratically more genuine mode of the production of natures can be achieved. A radical socio-environmental political programme, therefore, has to crystallise around imagining new ways to organise processes of socio-metabolic transformation. This requires first of all a radical re-politicisation of the ‘economic’ as it is exactly the latter that structures socio-metabolic processes. But this is predicated upon traversing the fantasy that the ‘economic’ is the determining instance of the political. Recapturing the political means foregrounding the political arena as the decisive material and symbolic space, as the space from which different socio-environmental futures can be imagined, fought over, and constructed. This, of course, turns the question of sustainability radically to a question of democracy and the recuperation of the horizon of democracy as the terrain for the cultivation of conflict and the naming of different socio-environmental futures.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.