Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

California proves UBI would result in a tax on small business and force them to go out of business

Wilford 22 --- Andrew Wilford, DIRECTOR OF NTUF'S INTERSTATE COMMERCE INITIATIVE. 8/22/2022 (“San Francisco Would Fund UBI With Tax Hit on Small Businesses”. https://www.ntu.org/foundation/detail/san-francisco-would-fund-ubi-with-tax-hit-on-small-businesses. Date Accessed: 7-21-2023.)

First and foremost, Prop K would represent an undue burden on interstate commerce, one that is likely to face challenges under the dormant commerce clause. The structure of the tax ensures that San Francisco-based businesses face significantly lower tax rates than businesses that sell into the city, as Tables A and B show, with no justification.

A main reason the United States has a Constitution rather than Articles of Confederation is to prevent sub-national bodies from attempting to fill their coffers with revenue from non-residents in order to offer their residents lower tax rates. Not only is this manifestly unfair, it is also bad for the country as a whole, as it unmoors the taxpayer from representation in the legislative body taxing them. Absent a federal government protecting taxpayers from states and localities trying to “import” revenue from each others’ citizens, interstate commerce suffers.

The burden created goes beyond just the rate increases themselves. Creating a separate tax rate for e-retail transactions requires small businesses to determine what is and isn’t taxable under the new rates, and track this in their accounting operations. Many likely will not have the capability to do so.

What’s more, San Francisco’s compliance burden increase does not take place in a vacuum. States and localities have been steadily increasing compliance burdens on businesses selling around the country for years now in an effort to glean more revenue from the digital economy, from economic nexus sales tax rules to expansions of income tax nexus to delivery fees. For small businesses trying to run their businesses and pay their taxes, it is death by a thousand cuts.

There’s another potential legal barrier as well. The federal Internet Tax Freedom Act (ITFA) prohibits states and localities from imposing discriminatory taxes on internet commerce. One such form of prohibited discriminatory taxation is defined under ITFA as taxes that are “not generally imposed and legally collectible at the same rate by such State or such political subdivision on transactions involving similar property, goods, services, or information accomplished through other means.”

Taxing e-retail transactions at rates that are several times higher than domestic brick-and-mortar businesses face appears to be a rather straightforward violation of this principle. Should Prop K be passed into law, it would likely face a strong challenge under ITFA. And for good reason — it is bad for the country if states and localities are smothering the baby in the crib by targeting the innovativeness of the digital economy for special taxes.

Lastly, while this measure will certainly harm small businesses selling into San Francisco and is structured to try to export the tax burden, it is likely to also hurt San Franciscans. Businesses selling into San Francisco would most likely respond by increasing prices or attaching surcharges to cover the added cost of doing business in San Francisco. Some may even decide that the cost of selling to San Francisco customers outweighs the benefit.

Conclusion

Responding to concern about the tax not applying to Amazon, Prop K’s backers have since suspended their campaign for the ballot measure and are seeking to remove it from the ballot. But they have also dismissed concerns about the impact on small businesses and, should they succeed in removing it from November’s ballot, will likely try again with a substantially similar proposal next November.

If San Francisco deems a UBI to be a policy priority, it should find a means to fund it that does not involve half-baked schemes to export the costs and import revenues. Not only is Prop K likely to create significant compliance and tax burdens on e-retail businesses for no reason, it will also send a message to businesses that San Francisco intends to take advantage of any business unwise enough to do business in the city.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.