Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Inequality at home hinders the US’s ability to assert global power

Tricontinental, ‘22 (Tricontinental: Institute for Social Research, international institute and think tank, “seek to bridge academic production and political and social movements in order to promote critical thinking and stimulate debates and research” The TriContinental, October 21, 2022, “The Geopolitics of Inequality: Discussing Pathways Towards a More Just World” https://thetricontinental.org/dossier-57-geopolitics-of-inequality/ - Emery)

I provide comprehensive evidence that the United States has benefited tremendously from the LIO, and show how critics understate both those benefits and the risks of selective disengagement. I also argue, however, that the gains have been unevenly distributed within the United States. The unequal distribution of gains from international economic exchange is a recognized problem in the theoretical literature advocating a liberal economic order.5 Globalization can create an enduring division between winners and losers unless investments are made in education and health, so that new generations can compete, and unless labour market adjustment programmes facilitate workers’ transition from declining to expanding industries. Redistributive policies, including access to post-secondary education, are necessary to ensure that more Americans partake in the gains from international involvement and to shore up the domestic foundations of the LIO. In exploring how economic and political inequality within the United States has impinged on its ability to assert hegemonic leadership, I argue that an ‘us vs them’ sentiment, internationally vis-à-vis other countries, and domestically vis-àvis non-white ethnic groups, was the primary force behind Trump’s electoral triumph. While previous presidents have more or less recommitted the United States to an internationalist foreign policy in the face of rising inequality, Trump detected festering economic and political wounds within the United States. The announcement of an intention to ‘make America great again’ resonated strongly with citizens of a Great Power who hardly felt economically privileged in relation to the rest of the world, and with white non-college-educated voters who were told they benefited from ‘white privilege’ while experiencing economic hardship and political alienation. Thus, contrary to Stiglitz, for example, who sees income inequalities in ‘white America’ as the main threat to the LIO—but does not problematize why white voters voted differently from other Americans in the same income bracket—I see political inequalities, particularly the appeal of ‘white America first’ among the white non-college-educated electorate, as a major threat to the LIO.6 The article is structured as follows. First I present the criticism of the LIO embodied in the ‘America first’ agenda as expressed on the campaign trail and in Trump’s inaugural promises. Second, I draw on International Relations (IR) theory to better understand both criticisms of the LIO and the rise of Trumpism. Third, I propose an alternative reading of the challenges the LIO confronts in both its international and it domestic foundations, as well as the relationship between the two. The final section offers concluding thoughts.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.