Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The aff’s mandate of fiscal redistribution follows the rationality of neoliberal welfare policy as a form of biopower—public finance is a tool to spread and enforce norms and fails to actually solve for inequality

Gürkan 18 (Ceyhun Gürkan is an associate professor at Ankara University. “Foucault, Public Finance, and Neoliberal Governmentality: A Critical Sociological Analysis,” Yönetim ve Ekonomi Dergisi. December 28 2018. https://doi.org/10.18657/yonveek.449581) @ehatt

‘Governmentality’, a neologism by Foucault, is a complex and sustained historical process that has started in the sixteenth century and established a general economy of the power execution in which the problem of government has been positioned at the core of politics as a result of the displacement of the central place of sovereign and disciplinary modes of power in the course of time (Foucault, 2007: 108). In a more general context, governmentality signifies a radical change in the rationality and exercise of political power in the sixteenth century. Governmentality gains its historical meaning in a complex process in which “institutions, procedures, analyses and reflections, calculations, and tactics” develop so as to allow a new economy of power to function by taking “population as its target”, “political economy as its major form of knowledge”, and “apparatuses of security as its essential technical instrument” (2007: 108). The notion of governmentality at present denotes the modern mode of power incidental to security and risk management concerns according to which the past modalities of power (i.e. sovereignty and discipline) have been radically reconfigured. That said, Foucault analyses liberalism and neoliberalism as part of his explorations into the history of governmentality. On this ground, neoliberalism is understood as a specific political reason and an assembly of techniques that bear on the conduct of individuals in private and social realms and carve out public policies for the state in accordance with the aim of ‘economization’ of all aspects of life (Brown, 2015). In addition to the constant and endless economization of the non-economic fields of reflection and practices, Foucault’s analysis shows that neoliberalism as an “active governmentality” (Foucault, 2008: 121) is a constructivist political reason. What is significant in Foucault’s analysis of classical liberalism and neoliberalism is that he does not regard them as ideologies and political philosophy. Instead, (neo)liberalism for Foucault (2008) is an ensemble of governmental techniques whose hinge joint is economics as the ‘knowledge-power’ and the market as the governmental rationality. At this juncture, the context of Foucault’s focus on public finance issues is the role of the fiscal system in establishing certain neoliberal norms in the conducts and habits of thought of individuals as well as in the state reason and policies. In this framework, Foucault (2008: 202-207) considers ‘negative tax’ to demonstrate the neoliberal governmentality of public finance. The negative tax in Foucault’s discussion appears as the instrument of a new social policy that is geared towards establishing a new social security system in transition to neoliberalism in France during the 1970s. The aim of the negative tax is to replace the social/public expenditures of the state for social security and protection. According to the economics of neoliberal governmentality, public expenditures cannot ensure an effective social protection and security for the poor and the needy. As it leads to a widening collective consumption, the wealthiest part of the population receives the most benefit and the effective allocation of sources in the economy comes to grief. In a sense, for neoliberal economics, any collective consumption somehow paves the way for the increasing monopoly consumption. The supporters of the negative tax argue that instead of the employment of public expenditure which stems from the will of the state external to the market logic and rationality, a direct cash payment should be provided at the minimum level for the poor and the needy so as to keep them always being ready for “looking for work and getting back into the economic game” (2008: 204). Therefore, replacing the traditional public expenditures targeting society as a whole, the negative tax monetizes economy as a field of game following the commodification and individualizing logic of the market. Foucault identifies three features of the negative tax. First, the negative tax does not seek to remove the causes of poverty. It deals with the ‘effects’ of poverty instead of its ‘causes’. In fact, this is not peculiar to neoliberal governmentality. Foucault shows that the physiocratic doctrine was the first to formulate this security rationality that accords privilege to effects over causes. This is so because to govern according to causes is more expensive than governing according to effects and consequences (Agamben, 2013). This consequentialist security rationality which leads people to “live dangerously” (Foucault, 2008, 66) does not seek to prevent the crisis or damaging developments, instead, it deals with managing them through consequences they made for. As such, “[t]he negative tax will never function at the level of the causes of poverty but simply at the level of its effects” (2008: 204). The second aspect of the negative tax is to abolish the social policy that redistributes income in favor of those who need social security. The third is concerned with changing the function of public finance and taxation into the imposition of neoliberal norms, subjectivity and ways of behaving on individuals such as enterprising subjectivity, self-responsibility, risk-taking manner and competition not as the market rule but a social rule. Thus, as the negative tax provides “a general security at the lowest level”, it ensures that the economic mechanism of the game, the mechanisms of competition and enterprise, will be allowed to function in the rest of society. Above the threshold everyone will have to be an enterprise for himself or for his family. A society formalized on the model of the enterprise, of the competitive enterprise, will be possible above the threshold, and there will be simply a minimum security, that is to say, the nullification of certain risks on the basis of a low level threshold (Foucault, 2008: 206). By this account, public finance in the neoliberal context can be described as a constructive governmental technology that carves out state policies and a type of public organization at the macro level and conducts the behaviors of individuals at the micro level of everyday life in a way to spread the market logic to the fiscal and, in turn, non-economic social domains. Public finance, thus, in the neoliberal logic becomes a tool of producing and spreading norms and rationality of the market logic in an economization process. This governmentality conception of public finance extends the scope of fiscal policies and tools beyond their classical range of effectuations and applications identified with e.g. the legitimization and justice in taxation, and budgetary discipline geared for capital accumulation. This conception of public finance based on the analytics of governmentality reveals that the neoliberal restructuring and programming of the state, society, and individuals occur within a broader societal framework that involves forming macro policies plus governmental rationality, power relations and normative value system. Thus, public finance, a strategic instrument of the state, as part of “the politics of truth” (2001c: 13) that aims to create neoliberal subjectivations and conducts becomes an essential dispositif in constructing a “governmentalized society” (2007: 248) in which entrepreneurial risk-taking and self-responsible individualization are the most predominant norms and governmental mechanisms. In line with these sentiments, it is fair to say that public finance has achieved a strategic place in the neoliberal context of the state and society in imposing neoliberal norms onto individuals since the 1980s. Budget deficits, for instance, have always been strategically deployed to weaken the belief in the welfare state and central-planning government, thereby, enforcing budget discipline to open the ways for the entrepreneurial model of public management. By the same token, competition, consumerism, and policies relying on subjective points of view have become the essential hinges of taxation. Therefore, fiscal policies and discourses are also the components of the broader neoliberal-framed policies and tools that disseminate certain norms and habits of thought all over the society. In this context, public finance has become a strategic tool and an instrument not only as the essential part of austerity policies after the 2008 crisis to stabilize the dynamics of financial accumulation and secure profits but also imposing and spreading neoliberal norms, disciplinary power, and individualization over the society at large to socialize the debt and debt burden. At this juncture, it should be noted that Foucault’s analytics of government is in continuity with his analytics of power. In other words, government as practice and rationality is not dissociated with power and power relations. Foucault analyzes three power regimes which formed a complex of the power structure in which government takes place: ‘sovereignty’, ‘discipline’ and ‘management/security’. Sovereign model of power basically relies upon juridicolegal mechanisms and assumes a central power like the king or the state. Foucault (1978: 135-145; 2003: 239ff) is highly critical of the view that takes sovereignty as the unique source and the single model of power. The modern order of power relations is a decentralized system that is dispersed horizontally and vertically across society. Against the theoretical domination of the sovereign type of power regime for the understanding of society, economy, and politics, Foucault develops new insights into the order of power and in his ground-breaking book Discipline and Punish (1995) he describes another dimension of power, that is, discipline. Central to discipline are individualization, normalization, imposition of norms, hierarchization, and confinement. Finally, management and security as a model or regime of power relations are directly linked to liberal and neoliberal society. Management through security mechanisms involves certain (neo)liberal governmental apparatuses such as risk management, calculative rationality, competition, self-responsibility, free market economy, circulation of risks, construction of the market mechanism in the broader framework of social and political life, and extension of the market subjectivity to the non-economic realms. It is essential, for Foucault (2007: 8), to recognize that these three main models or regimes of power do not signify the distinct historical ages in succession in the sense that first sovereign/king/law (the Renaissance period), then discipline (17th-18th century) and finally the management of security in (neo)liberal power order from 18th century onwards came out. Foucault presents them as a historical series of power model that follow one another throughout history and this has led many to have an impression of the linear series of power regimes. However, this teleological reading of Foucault (Lemke, 2012: 89) limits the explanatory vigor of his analytics of government and power. For Foucault, the historical distinction between sovereign, disciplinary and security-management models/regimes of power is analytical to demonstrate their specific and evident characteristics. All these models/regimes of power have their own history of techniques but this does not mean that they proceeded and developed in history in a way to completely eliminate one another. Instead, in different historical epochs, each seized hold of the dominant place in the then regime of power relations by articulating others to its own. For Foucault, this complex assemblage of mechanisms of different regimes/models of power produces “the general economy of power” (Foucault, 2007: 10). This means that the present society of security is made up of the diverse components of power apparatuses of the sovereign and disciplinary regimes of power modified in accordance with the management model of security mechanisms. In Foucault’s words, “technologies [of security] consist. . . in the reactivation and transformation of the juridico-legal techniques and the disciplinary techniques” (2007: 9). In the following, he adds, “the security is a way of making the old armatures of law and discipline function in addition to the specific mechanisms of security” (2007: 10). Foucault’s remarks on the security-type power regime in relation to other modalities of power i.e. discipline, sovereignty, and domination, are of great importance to fathom the essence of neoliberal governmentality. Foucault himself informs governmentality as a complex assemblage of ‘technologies of domination’ and ‘technologies of the self’. “This encounter between the technologies of domination of others and those of the self”, writes Foucault, “I call ‘governmentality’” (1997: 225). Foucault’s emphatic emphasize on the combination of different modalities of power is as important as his insights into the analytical and historical distinction between them to achieve an understanding of the role of the state and fiscal regime as part of broader neoliberal power and governmental regime. The 2008 crisis has blatantly demonstrated that neoliberal fiscal policies and rationality do not revolve around the presumed ideal norms and mechanisms of the laissez-faire market economy, but they are closely tied into disciplinary and domineering norms and techniques. Therefore, the neoliberal governmentality of public finance can be explained in the framework of Foucault’s triangle of power regimes that signifies the inextricable integration of sovereignty, discipline, and security management. The following section presents an evaluation of the neoliberal governmentality of public finance in its relation to the combined effects of diverse power regimes. II. THE CHANGING PATTERNS AND CONDITIONS OF NEOLIBERAL GOVERNMENTALITY AND PUBLIC FINANCE AFTER FOUCAULT In looking at the literature, few authors draw attention to the public finance from the perspective of governmentality after Foucault. Amongst them, Nikolas Rose (1993; 1996) and Peter Miller (2008, with Rose) refer to budget and budgetization as the mechanism of self-technology and rationalization pertain to neoliberal governmentality in advanced liberal countries. Budget and budgetization are seen as the essential sites and means of advancing expert knowledge, calculative rationalities and self-disciplinary procedures in governing individuals and population. Taking inspiration from Rose and Miller, Stephan Collier (2007; 2011) makes an important contribution to the analysis of budget as social technology and budgetization as the rationalization of government in the context of and transition to neoliberalism. Collier’s studies are based upon the case of the Russian industrial city Belaya Kalitva in the post-Soviet period and aim to explain how the city has gone under a great transformation towards a social modernity managed by neoliberal governmentality. Following Max Weber’s distinction between formal and substantive rationality, Collier argues that neoliberal governmentality and budgetary processes are not limited to the formal/calculative rationality which is carved out by the market logic. Collier identifies the substantive dimension of neoliberal governmentality and budget/budgetary rationalization, which suggests that governing population and individuals requires taking into consideration the long-term historical structures, norm systems, relations and cultural attitudes of the population. In doing so, Collier shows that neoliberal governmentality is not only concerned with the elimination of the centralized bureaucratic social welfare and planning system through the market mechanisms and formal rationality but also with the transformation and reconstruction of the embedded social structures, milieu, norms and values. This means that instead of pursuing a sharp rupture with the past, neoliberalism works on the continuity of the past values by articulating them to the grid of new societal system. The budget as a social technology is at the service of the neoliberal art of government to rebuild and govern society within its actual, historical and substantive conditions. Based upon the case study Collier argues that life at its micro and macro extent is the target in the process of constitution of social modernity through neoliberal budgetary practices and procedures which would be considered to be ‘biopolitical’ technologies of neoliberal governmentality concerned with both continuities and discontinuities. Thus, budget as a neoliberal social and biopolitical technology engages in the redistribution of the sources among the races, ethnicities, genders, sexualities and other specific classifications of the life with an eye to improving and spreading the market rationality. Following Collier, it is fair to say that budget as a biopolitical technology in neoliberal governmentality comes into play with strong microeconomic effects. As budgetary policies and rationalization which seek to establish symmetry between the budgets of official administrative units and those of households target the substantive and institutional transformation of individuals and society, the formalist rationality and calculative reasoning are, on the other side, founded on rational political-economy choices of individuals as opposed to central economic/fiscal planning. Budget becomes the managerial grid of extensive economic and political rationalization processes and it is deployed both as a constructive technology of the social control and self-technology in a way to make individual sovereign through the modification of his/her substantive habituation which is still subject to the macro-fiscal discipline. What is more, this does not exclude expert knowledge and management, and rational calculation of budgeting; they shift from the domain of central units of government to individuals. In this sense, Collier characterizes neoliberal governmentality and biopolitical government as the microeconomic critique of the welfare state bringing forward individuals’ choices geared towards re-programming of the society on the basis of micro foundations of power relations. As public choice theory contemplates, the calculative/formal rationality of taxation and expenditures is highly decentralized and becomes dependent upon choices, preferences and the power of political bargaining of the autonomous individuals and local units. The scope of public finance is not confined to the subject of scarce resource allocation managed by the central economic/fiscal planning institutions. Neoliberal governmentality employing budget as a biopolitical apparatus targets to undermine the ‘social capitalism’ in which individuals are envisioned as living encapsulated in an ‘iron cage’ that forces them to act like the state officials in their daily and private lives regulated by the bureaucratic rules instead of an autonomous and free individuals acting out of their own will to decide around self-preferences and -choices (Sennett, 2006: 33).

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.