Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Anticyclical Link: Conditioning financial support on labor market contributions turns citizens into passive subjects whose primary moral obligation is to serve the capitalist system.

Matthew Cooper 20 {Associate Lecturer, Department of Sociology at Wentworth College} - ("‘21st Century Welfare’ in Historical Perspective: Disciplinary Welfare in the Depression of the 1930s and Its Implications for Today," Sage Journals, published 7-20-2020, accessed 7-13-2023, https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/1360780420937741)//LF/

Governmentality literature in social policy follows Foucault by focusing ‘on the intervention of the state through organizations, procedures, rules and categories’ (Boland, 2016: 3). Of central interest is how administrators or governors perceive subjects and populations and how ideal outcomes and subjects are constituted in discourse and translated into techniques of governance. Disciplinary power ‘‘makes’ individuals; it is the specific technique of a power that regards individuals both as objects and as instruments of its exercise’ (Foucault, 1977: 170). It is a matter ‘of “making up” citizens capable of bearing a kind of regulated freedom’ (Rose and Miller, 2010: 272). With regard to unemployment benefits, disciplinary measures seek to ‘make up’ a subject that can be (and seeks to be Peeters, 2013) re-integrated into the labour market and no longer dependent upon state funds (Dean, 1995). Foucault’s recently published (in English) lectures On the Punitive Society (2015), delivered in the run-up to the publication of Discipline and Punish (1977), provide an interesting supplement to the latter. They contain a greater focus on the development of policing, driven by developing capitalist production. They show that disciplinary social policy is not neutral regarding the labour market; economic liberalism ‘and disciplinary techniques are completely bound up with each other’ (Foucault, 2010: 66). Conditionality is a capitalist technology seeking to enforce ‘the worker’s duty to offer his labour-power on a free market’ (Foucault, 2015: 173). The conditionality increases seen in the present day depend on a view of passive subjects, ‘workless’, and ‘dependent’, who require a firm guiding hand after a period of over-indulgence. This view also provides a justification for escalations which are represented as in the ultimate interests of the claimant who has neither the capacity to refuse (as an irrational subject) nor the right to do so (as the morally indebted recipient of aid). But these interventions are not applied evenly: their application is dependent upon a system of classifications. This differentiation and ranking of individuals can entail very different forms of treatment. ‘The distribution according to ranks or grades has a double role: it marks the gaps, hierarchizes qualities, skills and aptitudes; but it also punishes and rewards’ (Foucault, 1977: 181). In the UK, the different conditions placed upon those receiving payments, such as demands that they train, search for work, or carry out unpaid work, are stratified by the individual’s status within a liberal ‘moral order’ (Boltanski and Threvenot, 2006).

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.