Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Financial Liberty Link: the aff’s concept of giving people “financial liberty” is based in biopolitical control over people by the government.

Grenier and Orléan ’07 [Jean-Yves Grenier is a French philospher and writer, André Orléan was a former president of the French association of political economy (AFEP), “Michel Foucault: The Political Economy and Liberalism,” Annales. Histoire, Sciences Sociales, 2007, pg. 1155-1182, https://www.cairn-int.info/article-E_ANNA_625_1155--michel-foucault-the-political-economy.htm] [A.G]

In the third lecture, Foucault explains to his audience that, after having studied in his preceding books the specificity of disciplinary mechanisms in relation to the system of law, he intends in this course to reflect on the difference between discipline and the mechanisms of security. His ostensible objective is to “put a stop to repeated invocations of the master as well as to the monotonous assertion of power” (STP 83 [57]). This declaration testifies firstly to his becoming conscious of the limits and insufficiencies of a reflection on the social order in terms of discipline and constraints that does not take account of recent forms taken by the government of men. [16][16]“I said somewhere that we could not understand the… Above all, its fault is that it presents liberty, with the modern sense that this word takes on after the eighteenth century, as an ideology or a universal concept, a sort of right of man that would bring triumph in the struggle against the disciplinarization of society. Liberty, Foucault maintains, is something else entirely: it is a technique of power, a relation between governor and governed. Two political readings are possible. The first, “Foucauldian” in the narrow sense of the term, would take this affirmation as an advocacy. Let us not misunderstand: the liberty left to the population is used by power for the ends of control, and there is discipline in the liberty that modern governmentality grants us. Moreover, the fact that security apparatuses are the producers of the liberty that they consume illustrates very well this essential observation: liberties depend upon power. The second reading insists on the contrary on the fact that, governmentality being necessarily protective of liberty, it constitutes a type of power that merits reflection and that can exert a certain attraction. Both readings are possible, and one may suppose that Foucault was capable of envisioning both. The reflexive tension that runs through both courses, however, tends to make one think that, unambiguously even if never explicitly, their author seeks the second direction. A clue to this is given by the reflection he proposes on the state. Faithful to his method, he refuses to have recourse to such a general category of political philosophy. The state is not a universal, it has no essence: to understand it, we must “come from outside,” and understand it through practices, that is to say through the general technology of power. And it is precisely to avoid any risk of “circular ontology” that we must do the genealogy of the state on the basis of a history of governmental reason. This argument is only apparently exclusively methodological. For it also allows Foucault to initiate a strong critique of those who denounce the state on the pretext that it tends to acquire an unlimited power or that its expansion is historically irreversible. Such a conception is too reductive, because in fact it amounts to hypostasizing the state, according it something like an essence. Foucault situates the origin of such an approach in the German liberals of the first half of the twentieth century, whose discourse is taken up later, unknowingly, by the Left, or even leftist, critique of the seventies that identifies all affirmation of the role of the state with a form of authoritarianism, or even fascism. According to Foucault this position is unacceptable for two reasons. The first is that the interference of the state in societal affairs is from the outset limited within the configuration proposed by liberal governmentality. The second is that its intervention is necessary for the establishment of liberty.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.