Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

FJG is neoliberal poverty governance that makes work and market contribution a prerequisite to true citizenship

Sanford F. Schram et al 9 {Graduate School of Social Work and Social Research at Bryn Mawr College} - ("The third level of US welfare reform: governmentality under neoliberal paternalism," Taylor & Francis, published 1-1-2009, accessed 7-12-2023, https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/13621025.2010.522363)//LF/

Thus, globalization and neoliberal ideology should not be mistaken for inexorable forces necessitating a single mode of social provision (Hay 2006, Schram 2006). All developed countries are experiencing global market integration and feeling political pressures to adopt neoliberal reforms, but they are responding in their own ways. The United States, with its long-standing emphasis on market-conforming welfare policy and reliance on private agents of provision (Hacker 2002), has been the predictable epicenter of a global turn toward neoliberal poverty governance that is taking different forms in different polities. To understand the relationship between neoliberalism and welfare reform, one must engage the former as a shift, not only in the state, but also in the meaning and practice of citizenship. Citizenship is an inherently relational status, defined by the ways members of a polity are positioned vis-a`-vis nonmembers, one another, the state, and other major societal institutions. Thus, as the state has been restructured to operate according to market rationalities, citizenship too has shifted toward an economic register of identity and practice. The status of the democratic citizen, positioned as one who must decide and act collectively with others to gain preferred policy outcomes, has been eroded and partly displaced by the individualistic market roles of consumer, worker, and paying customer (Crenson and Ginsberg 2002). Citizens, in this guise, are synonymous with ‘taxpayers’ who have a contractual right to expect efficient and effective institutional actions that produce a good return on their investment. They are positioned, through vouchers and choice programs, as ‘consumers’ who pursue better goods from the system by exercising their individual freedom to seek goods from other providers (exit) rather than by joining together to participate in or demand improvements in the institutions they share (voice). They are encouraged to help others, not by deciding together how to organize their communities in a just manner, but by pursuing individual work as volunteers and charitable givers and virtuous providers of services. At the same time, the obligation to work and function as a ‘self-sufficient’ actor in the market is recast as the primary responsibility of the citizen and, indeed, as a necessary precondition for ‘moral standing’ as a member of society who merits equal respect, possesses full rights, and can be presumed competent to fulfill other civic obligations (Mead 1997). Under neoliberalism, citizenship is, as Brown (2006) observes, ‘reduced to self-care;’ self-care is reduced, in turn, to the singular project of ensuring that one’s needs are met through one’s contributions to the market. Uses of policy to make ‘better citizens’ thus become indistinguishable from efforts to produce docile subjects who comply with market needs and political authorities. Neoliberalism, in this sense, entails the ‘governmentalization’ of citizenship (Dean 1999).

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.