Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Investment in human capital is the core tenant of the neoliberal drive to escape the inherent contradictions within capitalism

Garrett ‘18

(Paul Michael Garrett, Senior Lecturer Dept. of Pol. Science & Soc. Galway University Affiliation, 9-17-2018, "Revisiting ‘The Birth of Biopolitics’: Foucault's Account of Neoliberalism and the Remaking of Social Policy," Cambridge Core, https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/journal-of-social-policy/article/abs/revisiting-the-birth-of-biopolitics-foucaults-account-of-neoliberalism-and-the-remaking-of-social-policy/7DF99E21282AA855D0541D470A02B46D, accessed 7-12-2023) //OC

In the second part of the ‘Birth of Biopolitics’ lecture series, Foucault turns his attention to US neoliberalism. Whilst sharing some of the characteristics of the ‘German model’, this variant originates from a markedly different national and cultural milieu. US neoliberalism is more encompassing than in the FRG and saturates the ‘whole way of being and thinking’ (p. 219). Foucault also acknowledges how US neoliberalism contains potent, popular components and a ‘sort of utopian focus which is always being revived’ (p. 218). It would, therefore, be misguided to merely perceive it as a ‘technical alternative for government’ since that would fail to grasp the project’s powerful affective dimensions (p. 219). Indeed, this aspect was reflected in the subsequent presidential campaigns of Ronald Reagan, epitomised by his famous ‘Morning in America’ TV commercial from 1984. Two years into the faltering one-term presidency of Jimmy Carter, Foucault identifies US neoliberalism as a ‘widespread movement of political opposition within American society’ (p. 193). He regards the 1930s as a crucial period and highlights the contributions of, for example, Henry Calvert Simons, an economist at the University of Chicago. The emerging corpus of US neoliberal ideas were further shaped in opposition to President Roosevelt’s New Deal measures, Keynesian economic policy and a perceived inflation in the size of the federal government administration. Subsequently, the theorisation of human capital was to become pivotal in emphasising the assets (or lack thereof) of individual agents within a competitive society. Human capital ‘represents two processes, one that we could call the extension of economic analysis into a previously unexplored domain, and second, on the basis of this, the possibility of giving a strictly economic interpretation of a whole domain previously thought to be non-economic’ (p. 219). In short, everything ‘for which human beings attempt to realize their ends, from marriage, to crime, to expenditures on children, can be understood “economically” according to a particular calculation of cost for benefit’ (Read, 2009: 28). Primary definers include the University of Chicago economists, Theodore Schultz (1961) and Gary Becker (Becker et al., 2012). According to these theorists, human capital is comprised of two elements: one ‘innate’ or ‘hereditary’ and the other, ‘acquired’ (p. 227). In terms of the first type, Foucault asserts that we ‘do not have to pay to have the body we have’ or for our ‘genetic make-up’ (p. 227). However, he invites us to engage in a bit of ‘science fiction’ and imagine how genetic risk profiling, and the related genetic matching of parents might boost or enhance the ‘innate’ capital of their offspring (p. 228). In later years, pre-birth screening has, in fact, become associated with greater calculation in this respect and more advanced forms of genetic engineering have multiplied these possibilities (Cooper, 2008). On another level, the increase in recourse to cosmetic surgery to alter and enhance given appearances has also occurred. Turning to acquired human capital, Foucault suggests this is the form that most interests US neoliberals and this is reflected in their preoccupation with ‘the more or less voluntary formation of human capital in the course of individual lives’ (p. 229). How do individuals evolve into ‘abilities-machines’ to enhance their incomes? (p. 229). What in the ‘child’s family life will produce human capital? What type of stimuli, form of life, and relationship with parents, adults and others can be crystallized into human capital?’ (p. 230). This is a grid of intelligibility in which ‘all the problems of health care and public hygiene must, or at any rate can, be rethought as elements which may or may not improve human capital’ (p. 230). Important here, therefore, are ‘educational investments’ which are ‘much broader than simple schooling or professional training’ (p. 229). This might include, for example, the ‘time parents devote to their children outside of simple educational activities’ (p. 229). The entire set of cultural stimuli received by the child will collectively contribute to the formation of acquired human capital. In this context, ‘more educated parents will form a higher human capital than parents with less education’ (p. 229). However, with a ‘whole environmental analysis’ of the child’s life, it will be ‘possible to calculate, and to a certain extent to quantify, or at any rate measure’ the ‘possibilities of investment in human capital’ (pp. 229–30; see also Gudmand-Høyer and Hjorth, 2009). Foucault takes child attachment discourse and situates it within his articulation of neoliberal ideas on human capital (pp. 243–44). He is not interested in the gendered dimension inherent in this arrangement (Thornton, 2014). Nor does he draw any, arguably relevant, parallels with contemporary theorisations developed by the Italian Marxist Autonomists, around the idea of the ‘social factory’ or ‘factory without walls’ in which the whole of society is placed at the disposal of profit (Negri, 2005: 102–115: see also Garrett, 2014). On occasions, Foucault does refer to a Marxist framework, linking human capital to the work of Rosa Luxemburg. More specifically, the cultivation of human capital is interpreted as an attempt to counter the problem historically haunting capitalism – namely the threat of falling rates of profit – by dint of ‘innovation’ and investments ‘made at the level of man himself’ (p. 231). As people are turned into ‘abilities machines’, the honing of new skills, and not imperialism as suggested by Luxemburg, might be the vital new platform for capital accumulation.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.