Infrastructure is used by the state to feed representations as facts to its citizens in order to serve its own purposes.
Larkin ’13, (Brian Larkin Brian Larkin is the Director of Graduate Studies and a Professor of Anthropology at Barnard College, Columbia University, “The Politics and Poetics of Infrastructure,” Annual Anthropological Review, 8-21-2013, https://www.annualreviews.org/doi/pdf/10.1146/annurev-anthro-092412-155522) @ehatt + [A.G]
In the case of infrastructures, the poetic mode means that form is loosened from technical function. Infrastructures are the means by which a state proffers these representations to its citizens and asks them to take those representations as social facts. It creates a politics of “as if ” (Wedeen 1999; see also Apter 2005). The budget must act as if it were a realist representation, and those issuing and receiving it act as if it were a consequential document. In their poetic mode, budgets become “arbitrary symbolic acts” (Mbembe & Roitman 1995, p. 337) as much as techniques of governance. This notion is true anywhere but takes on particular intensity in many parts of Africa, where the gap between the public dissemination of a calculative order (e.g., size of a population, gross domestic product, etc.) is widely believed to be arbitrary. There, as Mbembe has pointed out, official job descriptions do not correspond to actual powers, positions are awarded for reasons unrelated to professional qualification, and budgets are drawn up but their execution bears little relation to them. At these moments the state is simultaneously both present and absent. Lea & Pholeros (2010), in their essay “When is a Pipe not a Pipe,” describe exactly this process in their discussion of aboriginal housing, which looks like housing but is not, in fact, housing. These are houses with pipes that do not connect to sewers and rooms that are only partially complete, “composite deceptions” as they term it (p. 191) that generate an “aesthetic order.” Pipes, in this sense, turn out not to be about pipes but about their production as a representational form that allows reports to be written, budgets to be satisfied, and sponsors to be mollified. A pipe may not be attached to an effluent disposal system, but it is attached to techniques of regulation, audit, and administration. Its material form is transposed from a hollow tube to digits on a budget and words on a page, and all these forms—as hollow tube, as number, as series of letters—are pipes. All are material embodiments of a pipe in differing forms that allow them to move in differing circulatory regimes. Pipes turn out to be documents. Recent research on Soviet rule has examined precisely the ways that rule operated as an aesthetic as well as a political project, one that constituted citizens through modes of address (Groys 2011). “Communism created ultimately effective aesthetic structures and defective economic ones,” argues the art historian Vladimir Todorov (1994; see also Humphrey 2005). He refers thus to the fact that the technical effectivity of Soviet factories to produce goods was limited, but its political power to train subjects in a particular relationship to state power, to organize management structures that preserved that power, and to represent it to the people through the object of the factory itself was extensive. Under communism, Todorov (1994) argues, “factories are not built to produce commodities [but] symbolic meanings. ... They result in a deficit of goods but an overproduction of symbolic meanings” (p. 10). Todorov here captures something that needs to be addressed. Infrastructures operate on multiple levels concurrently. They execute technical functions (they move traffic, water, or electricity) by mediating exchange over distance and binding people and things into complex heterogeneous systems and by operating as entextualized forms that have relative autonomy from their technical function. To conceive of this operation as a form of poetics in the Jakobsonian sense is to rearrange the hierarchy of functions so that the aesthetic dimension of infrastructure (rather than its technical one) is dominant. Thus many studies that begin by stating how infrastructures are invisible until they break down are fundamentally inaccurate. Infrastructures are metapragmatic objects, signs of themselves deployed in particular circulatory regimes to establish sets of effects. It is commonplace, seemingly obligatory, for almost any study of infrastructure to repeat Star’s (1999) assertion that infrastructures are “by definition invisible,” taken for granted, and that they only “become visible on breakdown” (p. 380; see also Collier 2011, Elyachar 2010, Graham & Marvin 2001, Larkin 2008). But this assertion is a partial truth and, as a way of describing infrastructure as a whole, flatly untenable. Invisibility is certainly one aspect of infrastructure, but it is only one and at the extreme edge of a range of visibilities that move from unseen to grand spectacles and everything in between. The anthropological literature traces out an enormous range of ways infrastructure is often anything but invisible. Sneath (2009) argues that electricity was such a central symbol of state modernity in Mongolia that it was referred to as “Lenin’s light.” This view is not too dissimilar from that of Anand to whom one slum activist in Mumbai could usefully narrate a history of water supply, betraying an impressive technical knowledge; in fact, the slum’s two pipes (and their sizes) were also known by the names of the politicians who supplied them (i.e., Congress Party two-inch-diameter pipe, Shiv Sena nine-inch-diameter pipe). For this system of patronage to work or for Lenin’s staging of infrastructural modernity to be successful, visibility was necessary to continually renew its political effect. Winther (2008) notes that rural Zanzibari had a highly sophisticated knowledge of the electricity consumption of each appliance they owned, and Von Schnitzler cites municipal engineers referring to Sowetan residents as technological experts for their ability to disassemble, reassemble, and hack water meters. The widely acknowledged depth and sophistication of technical knowledge indicate the impossibility of these technologies fading into the background; indeed, as Carse (2012) argues, all visibility is situated and what is background for one person is a daily object of concern for another. The point is not to assert one or another status as an inherent condition of infrastructures but to examine how (in)visibility is mobilized and why. Generic statements about the invisibility of infrastructure cannot be supported. Perhaps the most striking example of this hypervisibility is Barker’s (2005) description of Suharto’s ceremony surrounding the launch of the Palapa satellite. Suharto held a kris, a ceremonial dagger used by Javanese monarchs as a symbol of their rule. The dagger was encrusted with 17 jewels (17 referring to the date of Indonesia’s independence), and the button to launch the satellite was embedded as one of the jewels. Barker (2005) argues Suharto used the “satellite as a kind of modern kris, a ceremonial dagger to unify the archipelago under his rule” (p. 706). It is difficult to conceive of an infrastructure more richly symbolic and vividly present than this.