Social Security seeks to re-entrench state control and maintain insecurity
Koch 21 (Insa Koch, Associate Professor and Director of Anthropology and Law Program at London School of Economics, Aaron Reeves, Associate Professor in the Department of Social Policy and Intervention at the University of Oxford, 3-25-2021, "From social security to state-sanctioned insecurity: How welfare reform mimics the commodification of labour through greater state intervention," Economy and Society, 50:3, Taylor & Francis, https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/03085147.2020.1844936, 449-450) @HA?
The organizing logic of social security systems is currently marked by a tension. On the one hand, unlike the ‘classical’ arrangements of high-income post-war welfare states, social security policy is no longer framed primarily in terms of decommodifying labour and collectivizing the risks associated with capitalism (Esping-Andersen, 1990). Instead, it is predominantly seen through its potential to create unsustainable public spending and high levels of public debt, or its unintended impact on welfare dependency (Hills, 2014). This discursive shift toward welfare state retrenchment is manifest in reforms which have reduced government spending, recommodified labour, and privatized risks by reconfiguring the conditions of entitlements and the structure of financial support (Hills, 2011; Pierson, 1994; Timmins, 2017). On the other hand, however, implementing welfare state retrenchment has been far from easy (Hacker, 2004). Indeed, in many ways the basic contours of the social policy landscape remain relatively unchanged. This is particularly true if we look at overall public expenditure on social policies for most high-income countries, even those considered to be more liberal (or more commodified), such as the United Kingdom. This is because cuts are difficult to implement, as harms are typically concentrated on vulnerable groups, whereas the benefits politicians accrue by implementing such cuts are diffuse (Pierson, 1994). In this paper, we analyse the design and implementation of Universal Credit (UC) in the United Kingdom to illustrate how this tension – between the resistance to privatizing risks and the costs associated with welfare dependency – gets instantiated. UC has been described as ‘one of the boldest and most radical reforms since Beveridge’ because it streamlines the system of existing benefits, bringing together six different forms of social security into a single form of welfare (Timmins, 2017). This streamlining was intended to ‘activate’ citizens (moving them into employment) by making it easier to move between out-ofwork and in-work benefits (Hills, 2014). But UC does not merely institutionalize a mantra of ‘active citizenship’ (Reeves & Loopstra, 2017). On the contrary, we show the uneven, chaotic and at times outright disastrous effects of the rollout of this most recent wave of welfare reforms. As people become unable to meet its requirements, they fall foul of the system of conditionality and sanctions, which is ultimately pushing many away from the labour market, while at the same time communities that have already been harshly hit by a decade of austerity are further destabilized by the individualizing effects of a new digital welfare state. Drawing upon a mixed-methods analysis that brings together existing quantitative research with original qualitative fieldwork, we argue that the efforts of politicians and policymakers to place ‘active citizenship’ more squarely at the heart of welfare states has fostered the kinds of insecurities commonly associated with commodifying labour, all while leaving the state’s involvement in the lives of those affected largely intact. Unable to simply reduce welfare spending or recommodify labour entirely, policymakers have engaged in a process Thelen (2003) calls ‘conversion’, whereby the purposes of a policy or an institution are remade. In the context of UC, this means existing systems of social security are being reconstituted with the consequence that the machinery of the state is now assuming an ever more central role in creating uncertainty. Welfare conversion is not merely ‘privatising risks’, however, by exposing citizens to the insecurities associated with the market. Rather, we argue that these reforms are turning the state itself into the creator of certain risks by converting (whether intentionally or not) social security into a form of state-sanctioned social insecurity. This happens as particular state interventions – including those relating to work-related conditionality, sanctions, and the digitalization of the welfare state – have disproportionately affected some of the most vulnerable members of the population and further weakened the capacities for collective resistance in communities that have been most severely affected by welfare reforms.