Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Tax is a manifestation of state control and subjugation

Rosembuj 23 (Tulio Rosembuj, University of Barcelona, Department of Public Economy, Political Economy and Spanish Economy, 4-29-2023, "Foucault and Fiscal Governmentality," No Publication, https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4433233, 14-15) @HA?

II.2. From the Police State to the State Police. The tax is a direct expression of the supremacy of the State, be it police or heir to the liberal sovereignist continuity. The tax manifests political power and the continuous and regular subjection of the citizen to the reason of State, to acts of authority. The standard contribution is essential for maintaining the armed forces, security, and administrative expenses. The tax administration is statistical capital of privileged information. It supposes the accounting, the verification of private wealth, the file, the evaluation of the assets, the resolution of disputes, and, as P. Bourdieu points out, the accumulation of an immense capital of information (statistics) because there is no tax without knowledge of social wealth and the force that sustains it and makes it effective. A secret knowledge that confers more power to the one who obtains it and uses it either for his preservation or as a direction against the adversaries.25 The fiscal laws are qualified as observation police laws necessary for safeguarding the country's political organization. They are considered a manifestation of State sovereignty and of actual application to whoever is in the territory. 14 The tax power is considered analogous to police power and with strictly unilateral effects. It is a public order benefit to satisfy the financial needs of the public administration.26 The expected contributions are necessary resources to subsidize the reason of State in diplomatic, military, or police matters. Tax collection grew exponentially starting in the 18th century. The Administration perfects the coercive power of the State that does not resent the privatization of its rustic, industrial, and commercial property. Fiscal power is like police power, and its effect is strictly unilateral. The general duty to contribute to public spending is the taxpayer's pure public order duty. Civic misconduct, including non-payment of the tax or resistance, was identified as a disturbance of public order. The fiscal power of the authority had no effective legal limitation and regularly exercised the regulatory coup d'état(Foucault). The law is the theoretical domain of the patrimonial and personal security freedoms, and its development and performance remain the domain of the Administration. "L'impôt is necessairement lié a la forcé qui le fonde et qui le rend possible. Ces opérations inévitables de violence n´avaient de chance de succès qu´autant that le pouvoir contributeur and engageait clearly are prestige et sa légitimé".27 The administrative power pervades the performance of the tax. And it is no coincidence that its legal interpretation is based on the Administration's right to its application, ignoring any configuration of the legal relationship that obliges it with the generic protection of the taxpayer. The legality principle during the liberal autocracy runs into internal obstacles, firstly, the elitist democracy resulting from the restriction of the electoral census and the vote and, secondly, the exclusive rights to ownership of legislative representation. The form of the tax law prevails over the acceptance, approval, and surveillance of public contribution (consent). The reason of State, the tax, is an unforeseen threat in the liberal autocracy, not so much because of democratic legislation, which does not exist, but much due to the expansion of administrative, fiscal power as a threat to the guarantee of patrimonial freedom. It is the moment when the bureaucracies and judiciary elites (state nobility) develop their interests and influence throughout the State. 15 Fiscal power is part of the reason of State, and, like penal punitive power, it is on the verge of threatening individual freedom in a broad sense

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.