Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The attempt to control the disease of unemployment through the mandatory experiment of UBI is a form of biopower that only exacerbates the states ability to control life

Mannevuo ‘19

(Mona Mannevuo postdoctoral researcher Contemporary History, Philosophy and Political Science, "Neuroliberalism in Action: The Finnish Experiment with Basic Income," Sage Journals, 3-6-2019 https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/0263276419834066) //oc

The randomised controlled trials used in experimental behaviour-change policies convey a powerful image of hard science. These imaginaries can be explained by the history of randomised trials as powerful and authoritative experiments in which the constructed evidence enjoys considerable rhetorical power (Edwards, 2007). Randomised trials were originally designed for medical drug research, so a trial begins with the selection of a target population, which is then divided into two groups: the treatment group and the untreated control group. Those in the first group, chosen at random, receive a placebo, and the clinical outcomes of the randomly-treated group and the control group are compared and analysed (Edwards, 2007: 10). This methodological setting forms the basis for the basic income trial, but in this experiment the ‘disease’ is unemployment, and the medicine is the basic income received by the 2000 people in the randomly-selected treatment group. The Behavioural Insight Team (2012) and the European Commission (2013) recommend randomised controlled trials for use in public policymaking due to their objectivity. According to the European Commission’s behavioural research team, this experimental setting ensures accuracy by observing people ‘in their natural environment without any interference from observers’ (Van Bavel et al., 2013: 14). Similarly, Ta¨nk (2014) recommends randomised controlled trials in its first proposal for trialling with basic income. Considering the trial’s experimental setting, however, it is worth asking whether the ‘coercion through implication’ (Whitehead et al., 2018: 126) in randomised trials targeted at the most vulnerable members of society can be seen as objective in any way. Recent interviews of the consultants and Kela’s responsible researchers on the trial further complicate this question. In The Guardian, a researcher from Kela hints that Kela hopes [that] additional data that is being collected as part of the trial from healthcare records will provide useful information on whether the security of a guaranteed unconditional income [...] might have a positive impact on anxiety, prescription drug consumption or doctor’s visits. (Henley, 2018) This is an interpretation by the journalist, but documents on the trial vaguely describe the strategy to get information on the participants’ behavioural changes from the data collected by the National Social Insurance Institution (Kangas, 2016a). It seems that the availability of big data allows researchers to observe first and ask questions later (Davies, 2016: 234). The logic of experimentation thus neatly dovetails with the biopolitics of behaviourism. Indeed, the uses of randomised trials are deeply rooted in practical biopolitical imaginaries. The method was developed in the early 20th century when industrialisation subjected workers to scientific management and at the same time turned the working population into objects of statistical research used to calculate and prevent risks. Soon, trials were used to identify at-risk subjects by conducting behavioural and healthcare analyses of selected target groups, such as mental patients and prisoners (Edwards, 2007: 16–17). In the 21st century, these trials are increasingly used to evaluate public policy, blurring the boundaries between clinical medicine and policy-making processes, as in the Finnish experimental study with basic income. However, this is not the only boundary these trials cross: they also circumvent the hard methodological questions of medical and social research. The experimental reasoning wrapped in seemingly benign intentions and naı¨ve optimism about the use of big data allows for introducing various state-led nudge policies ‘which would otherwise seem entirely unreasonable, or even illegal’ (Davies, 2016: 235). Experimenting with basic income promises to increase well-being and health but it also normalises and enlarges the huge apparatuses of power used by the state to conduct the experiment. Whereas voluntary participation, a common method in empirical and sociological research, is considered to cause discrepancies in the data, randomised controlled trials are considered to yield hard, factual knowledge, building a valid basis for reforms and legislation (Haynes et al., 2012; Van Bavel et al., 2013). As Olli Kangas (2016b), a research director at the National Social Insurance Institution, states in his blog post: It would certainly be possible to carry out the experiment on the basis of voluntary participation, but such a design includes so many potential sources of error that we decided against it. A voluntary experiment is only the second-best experiment! Given these problematised uses of randomised controlled trial methods, the basic income experiment offers a window into how behaviourism merges with law and experimental economics, creating a channel to disseminate neuroliberal rationality to constitutive elements of democratic life (cf. Brown, 2015: 151; Foucault, 2008: 163). To conduct the trial, the Finnish Constitutional Law Committee had to bypass Article 7 of United Nations Document A/2929 (1955), prohibiting states from conducting medical and scientific experiments without the free consent of the individuals involved. Planners dismissed Article 7 as irrelevant as it is intended to prevent abuses in medical experiments, and this particular experiment with basic income is intended to increase well-being (Kangas and Pulkka, 2016: 84–6). Hard ethical questions regarding mandatory, state-led experiments on the unemployed thus were avoided with the rhetoric of good intentions and the technocratic emphasis on the importance of learning ‘what works’ in fast-policy interventions (see also Peck et al., 2012: 278–83). In randomised controlled trials, the powerful, dynamic word controlled serves as a rhetorical device to reduce criticism as it creates the impression of a solution-driven method to organise the disorganised in complex environments (Edwards, 2007). These trials thus rise above politics, although, as in the Finnish case, they are strategically used to support political aims. In so doing, the culture of experimental policy-making is believed to overcome governments’ social challenges with juridicaleconomic instruments and the naïve belief that behavioural economics offers technical solutions to structural problems. In the next section, I show how these technical and behavioural interventions utilise nudge politics to push individuals towards cost-effective, healthier paths.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.