UBI strengthens sovereign biopower by excluding the Other from the national community, reinforcing a permanent state of exception for non-citizens.
Knowles 21
Anthony Knowles (BA in Political Science & Sociology, MA in Sociology, PhD in Sociology @ University of Tennessee), 2021, "Universal Basic Income, Social Justice, and Marginality: A Critical Evaluation," Social Justice, https://www.proquest.com/docview/2807107598?pq-origsite=gscholar&fromopenview=true //MLT
The first critique of UBI focuses on how it interfaces with marginalized communities and the potential dangers of a neoliberal UBI. The next two critiques explain how an uncritically examined UBI program could reproduce marginality in how it handles distribution to immigrants and incarcerated people. UBI is often framed rhetorically as a birthright for citizens of a country. It is a program of redistribution so vast that it can only be run by the state, and therefore is characterized by both the pros and cons of being administered by the modern capitalist state. Even though a UBI is called universal, there are still inherent limits to who counts as part of this universal. UBI implemented in the United States would be universally given to citizens of any race, gender, or employment status, but would obviously not be given to citizens of, say, Germany or Indonesia, nor to temporary visitors or tourists. This is an inherent limitation due to the nature of jurisdiction in the modern nation-state framework. This framework was inherited from centuries of national identity formation processes (Anderson 1983) and was congealed and fortified by the state's legitimate monopoly of violence (Weber 1922/2013). This therefore means that states ultimately have the power to decide who is entitled to a basic income, which can be problematic for noncitizens living in the country or those with an ambiguous citizenship status. In other words, the state has the power to define who is entitled to UBI and who is not, which ultimately gives the state more power to choose life or death, economic security or precarity, for those at the margins of inclusion in the nation. Though a UBI would be given to those who are unambiguously citizens of that nation-state, those outside that circle, those misconstrued to be outside that circle, or those made to be outside that circle by the state could be legally denied access to UBI. The state would consider this justified and legitimate as would segments of the public. This exclusion for those at the margins would be a kind of slow violence (Deb 2019) that may be further exacerbated if future waves of automation and technological displacement make gainful employment increasingly scarce. It adds another means for the state to exercise biopower, choosing which lives to foster and which lives to "let die" (Foucault 1978, 144) based on the state's definition of imagined community (Anderson 1983). Those who are not considered part of the imagined community, especially immigrants and refugees, may be barred not only from citizenship, but the minimum income as well, further marginalizing immigrant enclaves while citizens enjoy the benefits of basic income. This problem can be exacerbated by xenophobic and racist social structures and ideologies, as these various Others are framed as unworthy of receiving UBI or as not sufficiently part of the imagined community to deserve its benefits. For example, Bay and Pedersen (2006, 427-28) find that in Norway, a country known for both its racial homogeneity and strong welfare state, two thirds of the total sample expressed a positive view toward basic income, but approval among those who initially favored UBI dropped by 34 percent when reminded in a follow-up question that noncitizens would also receive UBI. This demonstrates the ideological power of nationality and how xenophobia can potentially damper the attractiveness of UBI. By putting the power to distribute UBI in the hands of the state, the power of the sovereign to make exceptions (Agamben 1998) must be exercised to carve out eligibility requirements for immigrants, refugees, and the stateless with various legal statuses. Such exceptions are already made in the US welfare system, as immigrants are barred from accessing welfare programs during their first five years in the United States and undocumented immigrants are banned from accessing them entirely (Fortuny & Chaundry 2011, Howard 2006). It should not be difficult to imagine that more restrictive admission requirements may be enacted to conditionalize the so-called universal program. A narrow focus on the domestic benefits of UBI leaves these considerations unexamined, allowing the universal in UBI to be uncritically accepted when the universal is in fact a particular that only has universal validity within a reified nation-state framework based around the imagined community (Anderson 1983). It is for this reason, among others, that Susskind (2020, 183-85) recommends a conditional basic income where the admissions policy for receiving it is clearly delineated. Such delineates are inevitable, making it vital for immigrants and immigrant advocacy groups to be wary of the eligibility requirements for any UBI proposal. This dilemma could also be described as part of the broader issue of border imperialism among modern capitalist states. As Walia (2013) explains, border imperialism is an alternative way of viewing state borders; rather than conceptualizing borders as protection from outside threats, border imperialism, disrupts the myth of Western benevolence toward migrants. In fact, it wholly flips the script on borders; as journalist Dawn Paley aptly expresses it, "far from preventing violence, the border is in fact the reason it occurs." Border imperialism depicts the processes by which the violences and precarities of displacement and migration are structurally created as well as maintained. (Walia 2013, 2) In this case, border imperialism defines who is in and who is out, who can access UBI and who cannot. Considering the immigration and border policies of the United States-under both Democratic and Republican administrations-and the European response to the Syrian refugee crisis, border imperialism remains the modus operandi of countries in the global north. This reality forces UBI advocates to ask whether the capitalist state, armed with the power to include and exclude, can really be trusted to implement UBI without reproducing precarity on the margins of society, especially for immigrants and others without full citizenship. The stakes for the millions of migrants, refugees, and stateless people of the world are too great to avoid responsibility. As the so-called third wave of UBI discourse continues among scholars, politicians, and citizens, it is important to confront such issues head on and seriously grapple with the implications of UBI for migration, inclusion, and social solidarity.