Social insurance is just another form of biopolitical control over the individual.
Peeters, ’17 (Ronald Peeters is professor at the University of Otago. He obtained his PhD from Maastricht University in 2002, and has been working as assistant and associate professor at Maastricht University until he moved to the University of Otago in 2017. Main fields of interest are game theory and behavioural economics.) - Peeters, R. (2017). Manufacturing Responsibility: The Governmentality of Behavioural Power in Social Policies. Social Policy and Society, 1–15. doi:10.1017/s147474641700046x
An analysis of techniques of government is, in Foucauldian terms, an analysis of governmentality (Foucault, 2007). We can understand responsibilisation as part of an advanced liberal governmentality, which seeks to work ‘upon the ways in which individuals regulate their own behavior to ensure this is consonant with the interests of the state’ (Pierson, 2004: 75).1 The objective is to make individuals conduct and evaluate themselves into alignment with political objectives (Rose, 1996b: 155). To this end, governmental techniques work on both the level of the individual and the level of the population. ‘Anatomic’ techniques focus on individuals and the individual body, as exemplified by the disciplinary power exerted over people in schools, prisons, hospitals, and factories. ‘Biological’ techniques treat humans as part of a population. Interventions take place on the level of the entire population, where humans are subject to regulations and policies that aim to mould them into productive elements of an economical order and manageable elements of a public order (comprising such topics as public health, crime, and welfare2). Through the two tiers of anatomo-politics and bio-politics, governments aim ‘to shape conduct by working through our desires, aspirations, interests and beliefs’ (Dean, 1999: 11) to be healthy, successful, and safe. Governmentality in liberal states emphasises voluntary obedience over coercion. Liberal governments are concerned with ‘getting people to act’ (ibid.: 119) in specific, productive ways, for instance by promoting an educated labour market and by providing social insurances against poverty (e.g. Ewald, 1991). Moreover, individuals must also come to recognise themselves as free and responsible individuals that shape their own lives through conscious choices about their future and their potential (Rose, 1999: 68). Liberal techniques are not limited to economic policies, but can be applied to any domain in which governments seek to use freedom as an instrument of political power. Instead of discipline, liberal governments pursue techniques of ‘security’ that allow ‘freedom of circulation’ (Foucault, 2007: 49) and stress prevention over correction. Instead of state control, they pursue mechanisms of self-regulation that make people act ‘responsibly’ of their own accord. Techniques to control and manipulate behaviour are built into people’s daily lives to mould their conduct, such as surveillance in the public domain, designing policies that ensure high levels of economic productivity (education, infrastructure, health care, etc.), and the implication of non-state experts and other actors (psychologists, planners, social workers, entrepreneurs) to manage social life. The idea of ‘individual responsibility’ is at the core of liberal government: ‘[ . . . ] a unitary, responsible self-agent must be supposed to exist because it is intellectually, juridically, and morally necessary’ (Douglas, 2005: 220). In its various conceptions, individual responsibility has been used as the prime mechanism for demarcating the role of government. In a liberal governmentality, the responsibility of the individual and the responsibility of the state are tightly linked. Changes in conceptions of individual responsibility legitimise changes in governmentality. Ewald’s (2002) historical analysis on shifting interpretations about individual responsibility provides a useful framework to understand how each interpretation is accompanied by a specific governmental intervention repertoire,3 as described below.