Welfare is the panopticon—informational networks within social program organizations entrenches the fear of the social worker as the guard—expanding social security expands the specter of surveillance and cements the state’s control over life in poverty
Van Haute et. al 18 ( Dorien Van Haute, Griet Roets, Maarit Alasuutari, Michel Vandenbroeck. ‘Managing the flow of private information on children and parents in poverty situations: Creating a panoptic eye in interorganizational networks?’ Child and Family Social Work. 2018. https://doi.org/10.1111/cfs.12433 ) @ehatt
Influenced by broader historical developments and contemporary pressures, child and family social work is often organized in categorical and fragmented ways at the interorganizational and policy levels (Rochford, Doherty, & Owens, 2014; Statham, 2011). The well‐intended idea of providing a differentiated supply of social services for families (Mkandawire, 2005), however, implies that welfare recipients often encounter substantial obstacles or thresholds at the supply side of welfare provision, preventing them from benefiting from high‐quality social services (Roets, Roose, Schiettecat, & Vandenbroeck, 2016. Moreover, welfare recipients increasingly seem to suffer from “the complex and multidimensional character of social problems in contemporary Western welfare states” (De Corte, Verschuere, Roets, & Bouverne‐De Bie, 2016: 4). In research, this phenomenon is referred to as “wicked issues,” “which cut across a diversity of service areas and policy domains and are too complex to be dealt with by single welfare organisations” (De Corte et al., 2016: 4). In recent decades, many countries have therefore initiated a countermovement of interorganizational networking to fill the gaps in social work service provision and to overcome deficiencies in the institutional division and distribution of welfare knowledge (Allen, 2003; Provan, 1997; Vandenbroeck & Lazzari, 2014). Also in the field of child and family social work, many efforts have been made to create interorganizational networks that involve a wide range of locally embedded social work actors (see Roets et al., 2016; Allen, 2003; De Corte et al., 2016; Frost, 2005; Garrett, 2008). In this development, interorganizational collaboration and the integration of services are perceived as systemic and sustainable solutions for the current and historical fragmentation of services (Allen, 2003; Anthony, King, & Austin, 2011). It is argued that interorganizational networking across many different actors in service provision may generate and cluster the necessary knowledge and resources to provide a productive and progressive response to better meet the multiple needs of children and families (Hood, 2014; Provan & Kenis, 2008). In this article, we explore insights emerging from a research project on interorganizational networking, which is perceived by policy‐makers as a productive strategy for tackling the wicked issue of child poverty in Belgium. Given that an extensive body of international research shows that child poverty has remained a stubborn, complex, and multidimensional problem in most Western societies (Platt, 2005), policy‐makers in Belgium and beyond believe that the struggle against child poverty may benefit from the creation of interorganizational networks between a wide range of local social work services targeting children and families (INCh‐project, 2014). In the international realm, it is important to note that although families are supposed to make use of social services provided by these interorganizational networks on a voluntary basis, our research project reveals that some of the child and family social work services being involved in the networks tend to acquire an orientation being rooted within a child protection discourse rather than in a child welfare discourse (see Parton, 2008b; Roose, Roets, Van Houte, Vandenhole, & Reynaert, 2013; Spratt, 2001). In this context, we focus more in particular on the increasing pressure that emerges in these interorganizational networks to document and share information about parents and children among public services (6, Raab, & Bellamy, 2005; Bellamy, Raab, Warren, & Heeney, 2008; Richardson & Asthana, 2006). Concerning the sharing of information, the network members depend on their own organizational rules, protocols, and background, so the local network and the families it serves are confronted with different approaches and regulations. There is currently no shared governmental policy on information‐sharing practices in the networks in Belgium (see Parton, 2008b, for a critical analysis of how the relationship between parents, children, professionals, and the state have changed in children's services in the UK, e.g., due to priority given to the accumulation, monitoring, and exchange of electronic information) and by consequence no standardized way of working between the services. In what follows, we therefore explore the complexities, dilemmas, and side effects that emerge in interorganizational networks of child and family social work services when they are handling the gathering, sharing, and (mis)use of information about children and families in poverty. More specifically, we focus on the major field of tension between supporting and controlling families in these information‐sharing practices. Frost (2005: 19) raises this matter when he argues that interorganizational networks may be “formed as practices that can ‘see everything’, ‘know everything’ and ‘do anything’, and thus they produce a ‘holistic power’ to discipline and control every aspect of welfare recipients' lives,” particularly in the case of documentation and information sharing. In this contribution, we theorize this issue inspired by Foucault's (1975, 1993, 2001) notions of the panopticon and pastoral power. In the article, this tension between support and control serves as an analytical framework to analyse our empirical data. 2 | INTERORGANIZATIONAL NETWORKING AND THE INTEGRATION OF SERVICES: A NEED FOR SHARING INFORMATION AND DOCUMENTATION In the configuration of interorganizational networks, the sharing of information and documentation has been noted as an essential aspect (Parton, 2008a; Reamer, 2005). Much attention has been devoted to the improvement of communication and to the sharing of information to enhance the continuity of service delivery (Allen, 2003; Anthony et al., 2011; Statham, 2011) and to avoid striking gaps and overlaps in service provision for families (McKeown, Haase, & Pratschke, 2014; Warin, 2007). The pressure on sharing information also derives from a protection logic and the need for a higher control of children at risk (Lees, 2017; Thompson, 2013). It has been argued that sharing information and documentation prevents the receipt of conflicting information, which often produces frustration on the side of social service providers because it results in a duplication of their efforts (Provan, 1997). Many professionals are expected to keep extensive data sets on clients to facilitate the development of multi‐agency interventions that engage the full range of their needs (6 et al., 2005; Parton, 2008a). Nevertheless, documentation‐ and information‐sharing practices may provoke challenges and raise pertinent questions about how the flow of information between services is managed in the formation of a network, because “in more integrated services information is likely to flow more freely” (Provan, 1997: 21). The manner in which information and documentation are shared is an important issue to consider, given that the flux of information can be difficult to control, particularly in a movement towards the interorganizational networking in the field of child and family social work. Moreover, making sense of information “is complex, with the needs of children and families often shifting” over time (Thompson, 2013: 191). In this context, we observe a major field of tension appear between controlling versus supporting families in the documentation‐ and information‐sharing practices of social workers. The assumption that children and families inherently benefit from documentation‐ and information‐sharing practices is questionable because these child and family social work practices may also have undesirable side effects and downsides. Support and control, however, often appear together and operate in a field of tension. 2.1 | Practices of documentation and sharing information: Creating a panoptic eye? Documentation and sharing information can lead to a reduction in freedom and an extension of surveillance over parents and children (Jeffs & Smith, 2002) and may interfere with their autonomy and right to privacy. When documentation and information sharing results in a narrow monitoring of clients, it can create renewed family policing and practices of surveillance. We can deepen this discussion by considering the notion of the panopticon. In its architectural form, the panopticon was designed by Bentham as a more efficient form of prison. With its central watchtower and its translucent cells, one guardian could overlook all of the cells. However, the panopticon, as Foucault (1975), Foucault (2001) analysed it, lies in the idea that each of the inmates can be watched all of the time, not in the question of whether he or she actually is. This is the disciplining power of the panopticon: the knowledge that one can be watched. It is achieved by the constant presence of light in the cells, in contrast to the dark in the central watchtower. It is the lack of reciprocity in the perspective of the guardian and the prisoners, however, that exercises the disciplinary power of the panopticon in which the guardian can see everything without being seen. Here, the question emerges of the extent to which an interorganizational network of welfare services may also create the effect of a panopticon. In its metaphorical meaning, the panopticon can be used for its relevance in grasping that continuous observation and supervision are possible in a network at all times. This is made possible by an increased flow of information: Documentation and information sharing in social work is a possible instrument of control and surveillance and a medium through which professionals can exercise power in the practice of assessing, judging, and documenting, particularly when they are brought together in a network (Roets et al., 2016; Roets, Roose, De Wilde, et al., 2017). The permanent visibility and observation lead to the automatic functioning of the disciplinary power. Supervision is exercised by individual professionals and social workers; however, it is not situated and individualized within one person but, rather, in a structure that makes it more anonymous and independent of those exercising control. In this sense, it is not clear who is watching what at what time; thus, children and families remain unaware of the precise nature of their visibility. Therefore, the surveillance is based on a system of permanent observation and registration in which documentation and information sharing may function as a method of exercising power, as “the documentation somehow detaches the statements from the people who have made them and transforms them into external or objective ‘facts’. In other words, the written word seems to give special weight and authority to the statement” (Alasuutari, Markström, & Vallberg‐ Roth, 2014: 99). 2.2 | Practices of documentation and information sharing: Creating supportive features in child and family social work? Interorganizational networks are, however, primarily installed to create supportive effects for children and parents in poverty situations. A supportive intention is clearly not necessarily in contrast to a controlling effect. This is perfectly illustrated by the concept of pastoral power proposed by Foucault. This concept implies a beneficial power, using the metaphor of the shepherd and his flock of sheep (Foucault, 1993; Golder, 2007; Vandenbroeck & Bouverne‐De Bie, 2006). For the shepherd to fulfil his duty, he must protect and care for each individual sheep to lead it to salvation. To be able to account for and guide the sheep and protect them from misfortune, the shepherd must know all of the information about each sheep. For him to know about each of the sheep's situations, Foucault (1993) argues, each individual must examine, verbalize, and publicly “confess” his or her behaviour and thoughts. This illustrates that the caring and protecting intention and the controlling effect appear together; moreover, disciplining power is used in somewhat implicit ways as the effect of care, rather than of mistrust and explicitly controlling intentions. This raises the question of the extent to which the relationship between networks of child and family social work services and children and families in poverty situations can be considered a form of pastoral power.